Top Auto Insurance Agencies In Wisconsin

Known for responsive and honest service, this agency offers a range of auto insurance options including liability, collision, and uninsured motorist coverage. The team helps customers select policies that meet state requirements and protect both drivers and their vehicles. Some clients note premiums can be on the higher side for seniors.

With over 45 years of experience, Prairie Land Insurance Agency offers a wide range of coverage including auto, homeowners, renters, and commercial insurance. Customers appreciate the team’s responsiveness and clear explanations, though some note the process can take a bit of time depending on the policy. The agency is known for personal service and competitive rates.

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency is an independent local agency that works for you by comparing policies from multiple insurers to find the best coverage and price. Their team offers auto insurance options tailored to various needs, from young drivers to empty nesters. Customers appreciate their helpful, patient service and the ease of switching to more affordable coverage.

Known for personalized service and attentive communication, this State Farm agency helps customers with auto insurance and policy consolidation. The team is praised for being friendly, responsive, and considerate of individual needs like low-mileage discounts. Some clients note occasional missed notifications but appreciate the prompt follow-up.

American Advantage Insurance specializes in creating personalized risk management plans tailored to each client’s unique needs. As an independent agency, they offer a variety of coverage options for both personal and business insurance, often helping clients find cost savings. Customers appreciate the team’s responsiveness and friendly, informative service.

With over 70 years of experience, Latus Insurance offers preferential auto rates for good drivers and SR-22 filings for those with driving blemishes. The agency helps customers find coverage that fits their needs, from liability to collision protection. While many appreciate the friendly service and fair pricing, some have found the home insurance quotes less competitive.

Frank Medina Insurance offers a range of coverage options including auto, home, flood, umbrella, and life insurance, often helping clients secure policies quickly and at competitive rates. Customers appreciate the team’s responsiveness and clear communication, though reaching someone by phone can sometimes take a few tries.

Reilly Insurance Services offers personal, neighborhood-focused auto insurance with a range of company options to help customers find affordable coverage. The team is known for friendly, knowledgeable service and assistance tailored to individual needs, though some clients have experienced delays with paperwork and communication.

Allstar Insurance represents multiple companies, helping customers find affordable auto coverage with applicable discounts. They offer personal and business insurance and engage the community through education and a rewards program focused on risk management. Reviewers appreciate the team’s helpful, patient approach and clear explanations.

Hornick Insurance Services, a Vizance Company, offers personal and business insurance along with employee benefits and safety management by leveraging broad resources. The team is known for friendly, attentive service and helpful guidance, though some customers note occasional communication challenges. They focus on providing comprehensive coverage beyond just rates.

American One Insurance Agency, LLC focuses on helping business owners protect their incomes with clear, bilingual service. The team offers personalized guidance on insurance options and is known for prompt, professional attention. Customers appreciate their thorough explanations and the genuine care they show throughout the process.

See Insurance Agency has been serving clients since 1998 and became an independent agency in 2009, allowing it to compare policies from multiple insurance companies. The team offers auto and homeowners insurance, with many customers appreciating the personalized service and competitive rates. Some have noted occasional issues with customer service responsiveness.

With a history dating back to 1974, Greater Insurance Services Corporation specializes in customizing insurance programs to fit individual and business needs. The team offers a broad range of policies and is known for responsive communication, though some customers have noted occasional lapses in service. Many appreciate the personalized approach and competitive rates.

With a history dating back to 1976, Parish Insurance offers a broad selection of personal and business insurance policies from various trusted companies. The team is known for attentive service and helping clients find coverage that fits their needs, though some customers have noted occasional communication concerns.

Since 2007, Adam and Jenna Stainbrook serve the state of Wisconsin, Michigan and Illinois. We have been honored as Top Agencies each year by the companies that we represent. But, what's more, we are proud of the friendships we have built with all the amazing people who we serve. We know that there is much beyond our control in the world, so we keep our eyes on what's important: providing personal… more...

Since 2007, Adam and Jenna Stainbrook serve the state of Wisconsin, Michigan and Illinois. We have been honored as Top Agencies each year by the companies that we represent. But, what's more, we are proud of the friendships we have built with all the amazing people who we serve. We know that there is much beyond our control in the world, so we keep our eyes on what's important: providing personal service for each member and appropriate coverage to cover you and your loved ones. Car ownership is an integral part of our lives. Our team can help you keep your car safe from all the bumps in life! For all your questions, please contact us. We are looking forward to hearing from you.