×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. US
  2. WI
  3. Top Auto Insurance Agencies in US
  4. Top 16 Auto Insurance Agencies in Wisconsin

Top 16 Auto Insurance Agencies in Wisconsin

Add Your Business

1

Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance

Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance makes the top ten list due to an important client focus. Clients, some of whom have been customers for years, commend the agency's excellent service, responsiveness, and thoroughness. Farther, his staff is also recognized as thorough, organized, and professional. The agency also offers competitive pricing for comprehensive insurance coverage, more...

Andrew J. McCabe: Allstate Insurance makes the top ten list due to an important client focus. Clients, some of whom have been customers for years, commend the agency's excellent service, responsiveness, and thoroughness. Farther, his staff is also recognized as thorough, organized, and professional. The agency also offers competitive pricing for comprehensive insurance coverage, meaning it is critical to customer trust.

Pros & Cons
recommend (4)
very happy (3)
friendly and hel ... (3)
great service (2)
View Profile
+14146227055
Open 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
4010 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211, USA
social-share-icon Social:
2

Prairie Land Insurance Agency Inc

Prairie Land Insurance Agency ranks in the top 10 due to over 45 years of experience, family ownership, and dedication to clients. The agency's customer-centric service is personalized through quick and affordable, dedicated care Linda and James provide. Positive and consistent reviews confirm their credibility and dependability. more...

Prairie Land Insurance Agency ranks in the top 10 due to over 45 years of experience, family ownership, and dedication to clients. The agency's customer-centric service is personalized through quick and affordable, dedicated care Linda and James provide. Positive and consistent reviews confirm their credibility and dependability.

Pros & Cons
recommend (17)
highly recommend ... (8)
very responsive (3)
very helpful (3)
unprofessional (1)
View Profile
+16082513009
Closed Now
2045 Atwood Ave Suite 113A, Madison, WI 53704, USA
social-share-icon Social:
3

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency made it to the top ten list because it's a local independent agency, which signifies that it represents the customers rather than the insurance companies. The agency collaborates with multiple top financial insurance providers and conducts price comparisons to better safeguard customers. According to verified customer reviews, the agency's emp more...

Pagel & Associates Insurance Agency made it to the top ten list because it's a local independent agency, which signifies that it represents the customers rather than the insurance companies. The agency collaborates with multiple top financial insurance providers and conducts price comparisons to better safeguard customers. According to verified customer reviews, the agency's employees, including Kelly Pagel and Linda Rudolph, offer excellent service and employ all necessary measures to better serve their clients. Hence, the agency is an excellent choice for clients looking for an independent agency with better service and reasonable rates.

Pros & Cons
very helpful (5)
recommend (4)
highly recommend ... (3)
extremely helpfu ... (3)
View Profile
+19205440687
Closed Now
1497 6th St ste e, Green Bay, WI 54304, USA
social-share-icon Social:
4

Meg Cano-Schuman - State Farm Insurance Agent

Meg Cano-Schuman - State Farm Insurance Agent. The agency delivers excellent personal client service with frequent positive reviews and an emphasis on accessibility and community service. Clients appreciate the agency's professionalism, helpfulness, and quick response times. As a result, the agency is the best because it meets and exceeds all customer service expectations. more...

Meg Cano-Schuman - State Farm Insurance Agent. The agency delivers excellent personal client service with frequent positive reviews and an emphasis on accessibility and community service. Clients appreciate the agency's professionalism, helpfulness, and quick response times. As a result, the agency is the best because it meets and exceeds all customer service expectations.

Pros & Cons
recommend (19)
highly recommend ... (14)
helped me (7)
very professiona ... (6)
rude (1)
View Profile
+16082382000
Closed Now
3565 University Ave, Madison, WI 53705, USA
social-share-icon Social:
5

American Advantage Insurance

American Advantage Insurance is one of the top ten insurance agencies for its exceptional personal service and tailored solutions. Client reviews emphasize the commitment of Chris, Joe, and the rest of the team to personalized service and accessibility. They examine and customize clients’ policies, resulting in considerable savings and a solution suited to its risks. Their revie more...

American Advantage Insurance is one of the top ten insurance agencies for its exceptional personal service and tailored solutions. Client reviews emphasize the commitment of Chris, Joe, and the rest of the team to personalized service and accessibility. They examine and customize clients’ policies, resulting in considerable savings and a solution suited to its risks. Their reviews detail the cordial attitude of the staff, the comprehensive coverage, and the ease of communication, which gives clients a sense of collaboration, family, and goodwill. Clients appreciate the agency’s independence, which allows them to find high-quality, affordable coverage from many insurers. The love and appreciation from clients show that American Advantage is a community-focused, customer-care-dominated, independent agency.

Pros & Cons
recommend (5)
very helpful (3)
highly recommend ... (3)
absolutely amazi ... (1)
View Profile
+19204068784
Closed Now
1794 Allouez Ave # A, Green Bay, WI 54311, USA
social-share-icon Social:
6

Latus Insurance

Latus Insurance ranks in the top ten because of its longstanding experience, excellent customer service, and cost-effective pricing. Clients appreciate the helpful staff, flexible plans, and the ability to assist drivers with varied driving records. Latus Insurance is less preferable than other companies because of its customer service, and some customers have said they are more more...

Latus Insurance ranks in the top ten because of its longstanding experience, excellent customer service, and cost-effective pricing. Clients appreciate the helpful staff, flexible plans, and the ability to assist drivers with varied driving records. Latus Insurance is less preferable than other companies because of its customer service, and some customers have said they are more focused on their bottom line than providing quality interactions.

Pros & Cons
great customer s ... (2)
great place (1)
very friendly (1)
great service (1)
horrible custome ... (1)
horrible (1)
View Profile
+14143212701
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
5232 W Oklahoma Ave UNIT 215, Milwaukee, WI 53219, USA
7

Frank Medina Insurance WI

Frank Medina Insurance WI made the top ten list by offering exceptional customer service and competitive rates. The company's clients mention quick responses, personalized service, and large savings. One client is quoted as noting that Frank Medina Insurance WI saves them over $500 a year. One customer mentions Frank Medina Insurance WI has excellent customer service in their ti more...

Frank Medina Insurance WI made the top ten list by offering exceptional customer service and competitive rates. The company's clients mention quick responses, personalized service, and large savings. One client is quoted as noting that Frank Medina Insurance WI saves them over $500 a year. One customer mentions Frank Medina Insurance WI has excellent customer service in their time of need.

Pros & Cons
recommend (2)
helped me (2)
service was grea ... (1)
very friendly (1)
View Profile
+14148770777
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
342 N Water St #600, Milwaukee, WI 53202, USA
social-share-icon Social:
8

Reilly Insurance Services

Reilly Insurance Services is a top-ten list member due to its prominent focus on customer service and economy, customer satisfaction, and dependability. Reilly boasts of being very professional and knowledgeable, showing respect for community diversity, and treating customers with dignity, respect, and compassion. Clients appreciate personal service, quick responses, and cost-ef more...

Reilly Insurance Services is a top-ten list member due to its prominent focus on customer service and economy, customer satisfaction, and dependability. Reilly boasts of being very professional and knowledgeable, showing respect for community diversity, and treating customers with dignity, respect, and compassion. Clients appreciate personal service, quick responses, and cost-effective policies, making them trust the agency. Even mixed reviews show that the agency has set a tremendous environment of work by responding to customer needs.

Pros & Cons
very professiona ... (1)
professional and ... (1)
helped me (1)
very helpful (1)
horrible custome ... (1)
horrible (1)
View Profile
+14144824461
Closed Now
3075 S Howell Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, USA
social-share-icon Social:
9

Allstar Insurance

Maxx is very professional and always available to answer questions. He is always friendly and knowledgeable. In my case the rates are very low. It has been an absolute joy to work with Allstar Insurance Company as a long-term customer. Highly recommend it. more...

Maxx is very professional and always available to answer questions. He is always friendly and knowledgeable. In my case the rates are very low. It has been an absolute joy to work with Allstar Insurance Company as a long-term customer. Highly recommend it.

Pros & Cons
recommend (6)
highly recommend ... (3)
very helpful (2)
did a wonderful ... (1)
View Profile
+14143759200
Open 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
8340 W Appleton Ave #400, Milwaukee, WI 53218, USA
social-share-icon Social:
10

Hornick Insurance Services, a Vizance Company

Hornick Insurance Services, a Vizance Company, is recognized as one of the top ten agencies for their competitive coverages, and diligent service. A few defined reviews were mentioned in a comparison of the alternate list for the company. Meanwhile, some customers commented that they had encountered issues, to which mostly the customer stated that they had worked with knowledgea more...

Hornick Insurance Services, a Vizance Company, is recognized as one of the top ten agencies for their competitive coverages, and diligent service. A few defined reviews were mentioned in a comparison of the alternate list for the company. Meanwhile, some customers commented that they had encountered issues, to which mostly the customer stated that they had worked with knowledgeable agents to meet their individual needs. Hornick is a full-service agency. Several businesses such as personal and employee benefits and safety management show the company’s range of capabilities. These factors impress customers because they are very service-oriented friendly and gain.

Pros & Cons
recommend (2)
highly recommend ... (2)
very helpful (1)
great people (1)
not impressed (1)
will not return (1)
View Profile
+19204998808
Open 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
801 Packerland Dr, Green Bay, WI 54303, USA
social-share-icon Social:
11

American One Insurance Agency, LLC

Rated among the top ten companies, American One Insurance Agency, LLC is dedicated to the client experience. Karina Castillo’s business acumen and fluency in English and Spanish guarantee professional, sensitive service. Client experiences mention her affordable premiums, superior assistance, and opportune solutions as well as long-term insurance assessment and preparation. more...

Rated among the top ten companies, American One Insurance Agency, LLC is dedicated to the client experience. Karina Castillo’s business acumen and fluency in English and Spanish guarantee professional, sensitive service. Client experiences mention her affordable premiums, superior assistance, and opportune solutions as well as long-term insurance assessment and preparation.

Pros & Cons
great prices (1)
recommend (1)
highly recommend ... (1)
very knowledgeab ... (1)
View Profile
+14145394036
Closed Now
3920 S 27th St Suite D, Milwaukee, WI 53221, USA
12

See Insurance Agency LLC

"See Insurance Agency LLC" becomes your ideal insurance solution based on its amazing service, competitive pricing, and extensive product offering. Customer testimonials laud the agency's personalized service, rapid response, and excellent rates. The agency's shift to an independent status enables it to deliver quality insurance handled by trained experts. However, you must pay more...

"See Insurance Agency LLC" becomes your ideal insurance solution based on its amazing service, competitive pricing, and extensive product offering. Customer testimonials laud the agency's personalized service, rapid response, and excellent rates. The agency's shift to an independent status enables it to deliver quality insurance handled by trained experts. However, you must pay attention to the lone negative review. **In Conclusion** Completing the agency’s Trustworthiness, superb product offering, and consumer praise served as the basis for its top ten listing.

Pros & Cons
very personable (1)
recommend (1)
very helpful (1)
horrible custome ... (1)
horrible (1)
View Profile
+14143555433
Open 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
7817 W Brown Deer Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53223, USA
social-share-icon Social:
13

Greater Insurance Services Corporation

Greater Insurance Services Corporation ranks in the top ten for customer service excellence. Clients praise agents like Lori, Sarah, and Julie for their quick responses and commitment to the client's needs. An extensive variety of customized insurance products are offered both for individuals and businesses. Due to its transparent pricing and local representation, Greater Insura more...

Greater Insurance Services Corporation ranks in the top ten for customer service excellence. Clients praise agents like Lori, Sarah, and Julie for their quick responses and commitment to the client's needs. An extensive variety of customized insurance products are offered both for individuals and businesses. Due to its transparent pricing and local representation, Greater Insurance Services emerges as a viable alternative to big-name insurance providers. Positive reviews recognize the firm for its history, professionalism, and transparent communication. The company's flexibility and adaptability make it one of the most reliable trust their customers have.

Pros & Cons
recommend (2)
highly recommend ... (2)
great company (1)
poor customer se ... (1)
View Profile
+16082213996
Closed Now
414 Atlas Ave, Madison, WI 53714, USA
14

Parish Insurance Agency

Parish Insurance Agency earns a spot in the top 10 ranking due to its strong commitment to customer service, personalized coverage options, and more than 40 years of experience in offering quality insurance to Green Bay and Howard with various leading businesses. The agency's independent experts serve clients from small families to big businesses to tailor competitive and extens more...

Parish Insurance Agency earns a spot in the top 10 ranking due to its strong commitment to customer service, personalized coverage options, and more than 40 years of experience in offering quality insurance to Green Bay and Howard with various leading businesses. The agency's independent experts serve clients from small families to big businesses to tailor competitive and extensive insurance. Parish Insurance Agency serves clients with professional consultation, a caring attitude, and knowledgeable staff that strives to find the most suitable coverage option. Most clients report positive experiences with dedicated agents who provide custom and cost-efficient insurance products and solutions.

Pros & Cons
super helpful (1)
View Profile
+19204689464
Open 00:00-23:59
2475 University Ave h, Green Bay, WI 54302, USA
social-share-icon Social:
15

Stainbrook Agency - Meemic Insurance Agent

Since 2007, Adam and Jenna Stainbrook serve the state of Wisconsin, Michigan and Illinois. We have been honored as Top Agencies each year by the companies that we represent. But, what's more, we are proud of the friendships we have built with all the amazing people who we serve. We know that there is much beyond our control in the world, so we keep our eyes on what's im more...

Since 2007, Adam and Jenna Stainbrook serve the state of Wisconsin, Michigan and Illinois. We have been honored as Top Agencies each year by the companies that we represent. But, what's more, we are proud of the friendships we have built with all the amazing people who we serve. We know that there is much beyond our control in the world, so we keep our eyes on what's important: providing personal service for each member and appropriate coverage to cover you and your loved ones. Car ownership is an integral part of our lives. Our team can help you keep your car safe from all the bumps in life! For all your questions, please contact us. We are looking forward to hearing from you.

Pros & Cons
accommodating (1)
poor communicati ... (1)
View Profile
+16085359291
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
2810 Crossroads Dr #4000, Madison, WI 53718, USA
social-share-icon Social:
16

Joski Insurance Agency, Inc.

Independent agents are those who have the ability to choose from many options. Our clients are our priority. We do not work for one company. Joski Insurance is a locally owned and operated business. Joski Insurance has a staff of experts who care deeply about your family and you. You're supporting the local economy by doing business with us. We also know your business and more...

Independent agents are those who have the ability to choose from many options. Our clients are our priority. We do not work for one company. Joski Insurance is a locally owned and operated business. Joski Insurance has a staff of experts who care deeply about your family and you. You're supporting the local economy by doing business with us. We also know your business and what your coverage requirements are. Never again will you need to contact a call center. Insurance for auto provides financial protection from bodily injury and/or physical damage resulting in a collision with another vehicle. It also covers losses related to the accident. Insurance may offer protection from theft and damages to your car caused by accidents other than traffic.

Pros & Cons
recommend (1)
easy to work wit ... (1)
highly recommend ... (1)
always been grea ... (1)
View Profile
+19204684141
Closed Now
1768 Main St, Green Bay, WI 54302, USA
social-share-icon Social:

Location on map

Our Methodology

Best 10 auto insurance agency list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Wisconsin is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

The Process

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing auto insurance agency companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 auto insurance agency category.

1

Business Verification

Verified auto insurance agency listings in Wisconsin are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive auto insurance agency profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Wisconsin .

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our auto insurance agency rankings in Wisconsin, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top auto insurance agency providers in Wisconsin .

5

Subscription

Subscribed auto insurance agency services in Wisconsin gain prominence with extra listing features.