×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Best Criminal Lawyers
  3. Criminal Lawyers in Indiana
  4. Elkhart

Best Criminal Lawyers in Elkhart

3 in Elkhart · 11 nearby
Elkhart Criminal Lawyers stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
3 +11 nearby
Average rating
4.9 27 reviews
Typical service price
$200 – $300 Median of 3 priced services
Most-offered services
Legal RepresentationLicense Restoration
What customers praise
recommend×20highly recommend×11absolutely the best×2great experience×2
Criminal law attorneyElkhart, IN

1

Christofeno Law LLC

Specializing in criminal defense, Christofeno Law LLC offers personalized legal services including OWI, theft, and drug case representation. Clients appreciate the team’s clear communication and thorough approach, though a few note occasional concerns about case outcomes. The firm also handles estate planning and business law with a focus on client understanding.

Services & Prices
Criminal Defense $1000 - $5000
Family Law $800 - $3000
Personal Injury $1500 - $10000
View Profile
(574) 622-1362
Open 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
115 W Lexington Ave, Elkhart, IN 46516, USA
General Services
Legal Representation
2

Cassidy Law LLC

With over six years of trial experience, Cassidy Law LLC focuses on criminal defense and personalized legal support. The team handles cases directly, offering clear communication and tailored strategies alongside services like powers of attorney and name changes. Clients appreciate the firm’s thoroughness and approachable, supportive guidance throughout legal proceedings.

Services & Prices
Civil Litigation $200 - $300
Criminal Defense $150 - $250
Family Law $250 - $350
Driver's License Reinstatement $100 - $200
View Profile
(574) 213-0761
Open 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
314 S 4th St, Elkhart, IN 46516, USA
General Services
Legal Representation
3

Ben Mattingly Law LLC

About Ben Mattingly LawBen Mattingly Law is a legal practice specializing in criminal defense and civil litigation, serving clients in Elkhart, South Bend, and surrounding areas. The firm emphasizes high-quality legal services, with a focus on personalized client attention and effective representation. The team comprises experienced attorneys dedicated to achieving favorable outcomes. The firm’s… more...

About Ben Mattingly LawBen Mattingly Law is a legal practice specializing in criminal defense and civil litigation, serving clients in Elkhart, South Bend, and surrounding areas. The firm emphasizes high-quality legal services, with a focus on personalized client attention and effective representation. The team comprises experienced attorneys dedicated to achieving favorable outcomes. The firm’s mission is to provide accessible, ethical, and results-driven legal support, setting itself apart through its commitment to client success and community involvement.CredentialsThe firm holds various industry credentials, including licenses to practice law in Indiana. Ben Mattingly has received recognition for his legal expertise and maintains memberships in professional legal associations. The firm’s reputation is built on years of experience, with a focus on integrity, professionalism, and client satisfaction. Certifications and awards further establish its credibility and trustworthiness in the legal community.Services OfferedBen Mattingly Law offers comprehensive legal services in criminal defense and civil litigation. The firm handles cases related to criminal charges, personal injury, civil disputes, and more. Its process involves thorough case analysis, strategic planning, and personalized legal strategies to meet client needs. The firm’s service areas include Elkhart, South Bend, and nearby regions, providing accessible legal support for individuals and businesses seeking effective legal solutions.Unique AdvantagesThe firm’s key differentiators include its extensive experience in criminal and civil law, a dedicated local presence, and a strong community reputation. Ben Mattingly’s background as an accomplished attorney and the firm’s focus on client-centered service set it apart from competitors. The firm’s commitment to ethical practice and community involvement enhances its standing as a trusted legal partner.

View Profile
(574) 218-0490
Open 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
215 S 2nd St, Elkhart, IN 46516, USA
4

Monterrosa Law Group, LLC

Serves Elkhart, IN

With over 34 years of combined experience and bilingual services in English and Spanish, Monterrosa Law Group focuses on criminal defense, immigration, and family law. The team handles federal and state cases while emphasizing clear communication and personalized attention. Some clients note challenges reaching front desk staff, but many appreciate the attorneys’ professionalism and thorough… more...

With over 34 years of combined experience and bilingual services in English and Spanish, Monterrosa Law Group focuses on criminal defense, immigration, and family law. The team handles federal and state cases while emphasizing clear communication and personalized attention. Some clients note challenges reaching front desk staff, but many appreciate the attorneys’ professionalism and thorough support.

Services & Prices
Green Card Application $800 - $1500
Visa Application $500 - $1200
Citizenship Application $300 - $800
Court Representation $1000 - $3000
View Profile
(574) 236-2953
Closed Now
418 W Jefferson Blvd, South Bend, IN 46601, USA
General Services
Immigration Law
5

Stanley, Tuszynski & Newman

Serves Elkhart, IN

Founded in 1972, Stanley, Tuszynski & Newman focuses exclusively on criminal and traffic law, using a team-based approach with attorneys, experts, and investigators to handle cases thoroughly. Clients appreciate their professionalism, clear communication, and aggressive defense, though some note the firm’s busy schedule can affect response times.

Services & Prices
Trial Representation $2000 - $5000
Appeals $1500 - $3000
Post-Conviction Relief $1000 - $2500
Client Representation in Court $2000 - $6000
View Profile
(574) 288-9447
Closed Now
110 S Taylor St, South Bend, IN 46601, USA
General Services
Criminal Defense
Where they are 14 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Jeff Kimmell

Serves Elkhart, IN

With over 40 years of experience in criminal defense, Kimmell Law Office focuses on personalized and aggressive representation for charges like DUI, drug offenses, and theft. The team is praised for thorough case investigation and successful dismissals, though some clients note occasional delays in communication.

Services & Prices
Record Review $100 - $200
Reinstatement Process $200 - $400
Filing Expungement $500 - $1000
Expungement Hearing Representation $1000 - $2000
View Profile
(574) 232-7410
Open 8:30 AM - 4:30 PM
218 W Washington St # 600, South Bend, IN 46601, USA
General Services
Driving Record Assistance
7

Brooks Legal LLC

Serves Elkhart, IN

Brooks Legal specializes in personalized legal services with a focus on estate planning, business formation, and real estate matters. The team is known for clear communication and strategic advice, helping clients navigate complex issues efficiently. Some clients note occasional delays in communication, but many appreciate the firm’s thorough and attentive approach.

Services & Prices
Child Custody $1500 - $3000
Divorce Proceedings $2000 - $5000
Child Support $1000 - $2500
Court Representation $2500 - $6000
View Profile
(574) 383-9544
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
511 E Colfax Ave Ste. A, South Bend, IN 46617, USA
General Services
Family Law
8

Britton Law LLC

Serves Elkhart, IN

Britton Law LLC focuses on criminal defense, including juvenile cases, offering straightforward advice and courtroom representation. Clients appreciate the team’s honest approach and respect in court, though some note difficulty reaching the office by phone or email between appointments. The firm handles case research thoroughly before moving forward.

Services & Prices
Criminal Defense $500 - $2000
Juvenile Cases $1000 - $3000
Juvenile Defense $800 - $1500
Felony Defense $2500 - $5000
View Profile
(574) 218-0989
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
712 E Jefferson Blvd, South Bend, IN 46617, USA
General Services
Legal Representation
9

Nemeth Feeney Masters & Campiti, P.C.

Serves Elkhart, IN

With over 25 years of experience in criminal defense and family law, Nemeth Feeney Masters & Campiti, P.C. offers personalized legal support through negotiation and litigation. The team handles complex cases, including appeals, and clients appreciate their professionalism and clear communication, though some note response times can vary during busy periods.

Services & Prices
Public Defense $1000 - $5000
Appeals $2000 - $8000
Trial Representation $3000 - $15000
Divorce Proceedings $1000 - $5000
View Profile
(574) 234-0121
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
350 Columbia St, South Bend, IN 46601, USA
General Services
Criminal Defense
10

Attorney John Kindley

Serves Elkhart, IN

Known for a sharp eye on prosecutorial errors, this criminal defense team focuses on exposing misconduct and protecting clients’ rights. They handle a range of criminal cases with thorough attention to detail and clear communication. While some clients appreciate the upfront approach, a few have noted mixed experiences with case outcomes.

Services & Prices
Felony Defense $1500 - $5000
Misdemeanor Defense $500 - $2000
Appeals $1000 - $3000
Post-Conviction Relief $2000 - $8000
View Profile
(574) 400-5094
Open 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM
1626 Lincolnway E, South Bend, IN 46613, USA
General Services
Criminal Defense
11

Kimberly D. Rife

Serves Elkhart, IN

Specializing in family law, this firm has served the Goshen community since 1955, offering support with divorce, child custody, and adoption matters. Clients appreciate the thorough and thoughtful approach, though some note occasional communication delays. The team focuses on guiding families through complex legal processes with personalized attention.

Services & Prices
Divorce Proceedings $1000 - $3000
Custody Arrangements $1500 - $2500
Adoption Services $2000 - $4000
View Profile
(574) 533-3181
Open 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
118 N Main St, Goshen, IN 46526, USA
General Services
Family Law
12

Hilgendorf Law Office

Serves Elkhart, IN

Hilgendorf Law Office focuses on criminal defense, offering services such as case negotiation and court representation. The team has experience handling traffic violations and more complex matters, with some clients appreciating successful outcomes. However, a few reviews note challenges with responsiveness and communication.

Services & Prices
Traffic Ticket Dismissal $100 - $150
Traffic Violation Defense $200 - $300
License Suspension Appeal $150 - $250
Felony Defense $2000 - $5000
View Profile
(574) 234-9950
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Fifth Third Bank Building, 218 W Washington St # 720, South Bend, IN 46601, USA
General Services
Traffic Law
13

Lee & Zalas, P.C.

Serves Elkhart, IN

Lee & Zalas, P.C. is listed in the top ten based on more than four decades of effectiveness in the legal field and a committed client-centered approach. Online reviews highlight the company’s professionalism, individual attention, and deep legal expertise, with many stating that residents feel like they are a part of the family. Clients have praised Lee & Zalas’ attorneys, particularly Clint, for… more...

Lee & Zalas, P.C. is listed in the top ten based on more than four decades of effectiveness in the legal field and a committed client-centered approach. Online reviews highlight the company’s professionalism, individual attention, and deep legal expertise, with many stating that residents feel like they are a part of the family. Clients have praised Lee & Zalas’ attorneys, particularly Clint, for being accessible, helping them understand complex legal issues, and treating them simply as clients rather than customers. The firm is well-positioned with excellent feedback and reviews. Above all, Lee & Zalas' reputation for giving dedicated, high-quality legal counsel is a deciding factor.

View Profile
(574) 232-5923
Open 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
54391 N 30th St, South Bend, IN 46635, USA
14

David Wemhoff Attorney at Law

Serves Elkhart, IN

David Wemhoff Attorney at Law is in the Top 10 listing because of his extensive knowledge in criminal defense, civil litigation, and transactional law. He is a South Bend, Indiana lawyer with a Master of Laws in International and Comparative Law and a Juris Doctor degree, which helps him capably represent clients in criminal courts. His strategic analysis, advocacy, and personalized… more...

David Wemhoff Attorney at Law is in the Top 10 listing because of his extensive knowledge in criminal defense, civil litigation, and transactional law. He is a South Bend, Indiana lawyer with a Master of Laws in International and Comparative Law and a Juris Doctor degree, which helps him capably represent clients in criminal courts. His strategic analysis, advocacy, and personalized representation regularly lead to victories for him and his clients. David Wemhoff has earned a reputation in the legal community as an accomplished, community-centered, and results-oriented lawyer, who has achieved favorable success for clients, like dismissing the charges against them.

View Profile
(574) 239-7005
Open 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
922 E Wayne St Suite 204, South Bend, IN 46617, USA

Elkhart Crime Statistics

Crimes reported to the Elkhart Police Department, 2025 (latest FBI data)

The Elkhart Police Department recorded 118 violent crimes in 2025 — down 5% from 124 in 2024. That is 220 per 100,000 residents — compared with 300 across Indiana and 329 nationally, according to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program. Police cleared (solved) 53% of violent crimes and 8% of property crimes.

Violent crimes
118▼ 5%124 in 2024
Property crimes
236▼ 28%328 in 2024
Violent crime rate
220per 100,000 · IN 300
Arrests
1,338▲ 8%1,240 in 2024
Property crime rate
440 per 100,000 (IN 1,252)
Most common arrests
DUI 199 · Drug possession 161 · Disorderly conduct 135
Weapons arrests
4
Drug arrests
169
DUI arrests
199

Source: FBI Crime Data Explorer, Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program, 2025 data as reported by the Elkhart Police Department, compiled by TrustAnalytica. Counts crimes reported to police; many crimes are never reported.

Elkhart Criminal Lawyers stats: 14 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 Christofeno Law LLC 4.8 21 $800 (574) 622-1362 Visit
2 Cassidy Law LLC 5.0 5 $100 (574) 213-0761 Visit
3 Ben Mattingly Law LLC 5.0 1 — (574) 218-0490 Visit
4 Monterrosa Law Group, LLC 4.4 105 $300 (574) 236-2953 Visit
5 Stanley, Tuszynski & Newman 4.7 78 $1,000 (574) 288-9447 Visit
6 Jeff Kimmell 4.6 56 $100 (574) 232-7410 Visit
7 Brooks Legal LLC 4.5 57 $1,000 (574) 383-9544 Visit
8 Britton Law LLC 4.1 45 $150 (574) 218-0989 Visit
9 Nemeth Feeney Masters & Campiti, P.C. 3.6 50 $800 (574) 234-0121 Visit
10 Attorney John Kindley 4.8 19 $500 (574) 400-5094 Visit
11 Kimberly D. Rife 3.7 15 $1,000 (574) 533-3181 Visit
12 Hilgendorf Law Office 4.2 11 $75 (574) 234-9950 Visit
13 Lee & Zalas, P.C. 5.0 4 — (574) 232-5923 Visit
14 David Wemhoff Attorney at Law 5.0 1 — (574) 239-7005 Visit

Frequently asked questions

8 questions
How do I choose the best criminal lawyer in Elkhart?
Consider verified reviews, ratings, review volume, and if the lawyer has claimed their profile. TrustAnalytica uses these factors for rankings.
What services do criminal lawyers provide?
Criminal lawyers handle cases like DUI, theft, assault, and drug offenses. They offer legal advice, represent clients in court, and negotiate plea deals.
Do criminal lawyers in Elkhart offer free consultations?
Many criminal lawyers offer free consultations to discuss your case and potential strategies. Confirm with each lawyer individually.
What questions should I ask a criminal lawyer before hiring?
Ask about their experience with similar cases, fees, strategy, and potential outcomes. Understanding their approach helps in decision-making.
How much do criminal lawyers typically charge in Indiana?
Fees vary widely based on case complexity and lawyer experience. Some charge hourly rates, while others may offer flat fees for specific cases.
Do I need a criminal lawyer for a misdemeanor in Elkhart?
While not always required, having a lawyer can help navigate legal processes and potentially reduce penalties for misdemeanors.
How long does a criminal case take in Indiana?
The duration varies based on case complexity, court schedules, and whether a plea deal is reached. It can range from months to over a year.
Can a criminal lawyer help with expunging a record in Elkhart?
Yes, criminal lawyers can assist in expungement processes, which remove or seal criminal records, depending on eligibility and state laws.

General information, not legal advice — consult a licensed Indiana attorney.

Our Methodology

Best 10 criminal law attorney list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Elkhart is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing criminal law attorney companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 criminal law attorney category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified criminal law attorney listings in Elkhart are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive criminal law attorney profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Elkhart.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our criminal law attorney rankings in Elkhart, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top criminal law attorney providers in Elkhart.

5

AI Search Visibility

Every criminal law attorney listing in Elkhart is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.