Car Accident Settlement Calculator Buffalo, NY
Work out your likely compensation and payout range from medical bills, lost wages and New York fault rules — free, instant, no sign-up.
Updated · lawyer rankings recalculated
New York: Your payout drops by your share of fault, but you can still recover even if you were mostly at fault.
Enter your medical expenses or lost wages — the estimate is built from them.
Towey Law, PLLCVerified
4.9 · 23 reviews · Free consultation
Free case review →
William Mattar Law Offices
4.9 · 411 reviews · Free consultation
Free case review →
Cellino Law Accident Attorneys
4.8 · 100 reviews · Free consultation
Free case review →
General estimate only, not legal advice. No attorney–client relationship is created.
Top-rated car accident lawyers in Buffalo
Ranked by TrustAnalytica from verified reviews · see the full Top 10 list →
Towey Law, PLLC
Towey Law, PLLC focuses on injury cases involving slip and fall accidents and medical malpractice, helping clients secure compensation for serious injuries. The team handles complex claims and stays in close contact throughout the process, though some cases can be challenging due to medical and insurance complexities. Clients appreciate their clear communication and persistent support.
William Mattar Law Offices
William Mattar P.C. specializes in handling serious truck accident injury claims with a 24/7 legal team ready to respond promptly. They assist clients through every step of the process, gathering evidence and pursuing compensation for injuries. Clients appreciate the team’s respectful communication and consistent updates throughout often lengthy cases.
Cellino Law Accident Attorneys
Cellino Law Accident Attorneys specializes in medical malpractice and personal injury cases, offering experienced legal support for those harmed by negligence. Their team handles a wide range of claims, including wrongful death and nursing home abuse, and clients appreciate their clear communication and compassionate approach throughout often complex cases.
What does an injury cost by body part?
Pick how serious the injury is. Each point shows the average medical bill for that body part at that severity; bigger point = costlier injury. Tap a point to compare it with the average workers’ comp claim for the same body part, which also pays lost wages. Then run the calculator for your own number.
- Head & brain
- Neck
- Back & spine
- Multiple injuries
- Chest, abdomen & hips
- Arms, hands & shoulders
- Legs, knees & feet
The Law Office of John V. Elmore, P.C.
With more than 35 years of experience, this firm focuses on serious injuries and wrongful death claims involving truck accidents, where federal and state regulations often come into play. The team handles cases with care and keeps clients informed throughout the process, though some have noted occasional communication challenges.
Morgan & Morgan
Morgan & Morgan focuses on personal injury cases, providing legal support to those seeking compensation. The team handles various injury claims and is appreciated for their attentive service. Some clients note communication can be slow at times, but overall, the firm is seen as reliable in representing personal injury matters.
Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law
Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law focus on Social Security Disability and workers’ compensation cases, helping clients navigate complex claims with experienced legal support. Their team is known for clear communication and steady guidance, though some clients note delays and challenges in benefit adjustments during long cases.
Brown Chiari LLP
Brown Chiari LLP focuses on representing clients in serious car accident cases, helping them pursue fair compensation against insurance companies. Their Buffalo-based team handles complex claims, including trucking accidents and elder abuse, with many clients appreciating their supportive approach during difficult recoveries. Some clients note occasional delays in communication.
Mazzu Law PLLC
Mazzu Law PLLC specializes in personal injury cases, including car accidents, with a focus on clear communication and personalized support. Clients appreciate the team’s responsiveness and thorough guidance throughout complex legal processes, though some note the firm’s hands-on approach can feel intense. Their background in construction injury law adds a unique perspective to their work.
The Coppola Firm
A women-owned firm with over 30 years of legal experience, The Coppola Firm handles maritime and boating accident cases alongside personal injury and business matters. Clients appreciate the team’s thorough, patient approach and clear communication, though some cases may take longer than expected due to their complexity.
Nicotra Richard A
Specializing in automobile accident cases, Andrews, Bernstein, Maranto & Nicotra PLLC focuses on securing full compensation for injury victims by handling insurance companies and pursuing court action when needed. The team is known for clear communication, patience, and a supportive approach throughout the often lengthy claims process.
Buffalo Car Accident Statistics
Fatal crashes involving cars, SUVs, pickups and vans in Buffalo, NY, 2024 (latest federal data)In 2024, 12 fatal crashes involving a car, SUV, pickup or van killed 13 people in Buffalo, NY — down 32% from 19 in 2023, according to NHTSA’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS). That is 75% of all 16 fatal crashes in the city.
- People killed
- 13▼ 32%19 in 2023
- Fatal car crashes
- 1217 in 2023
- 2022–2024 total
- 56people killed
- Occupants killed
- 7inside the vehicles
- Alcohol involved
- 33% of these crashes
- Speeding involved
- 50% of these crashes
- After dark
- 75% of these crashes
- Hit-and-run
- 25% of these crashes
- Most common crash type
- Hit a pedestrian or cyclist — 42%
- Deadliest times
- 6 PM–midnight · Sundays · peak month September
- Roads with the most of these crashes
- Broadway, Elmwood Ave
Source: NHTSA Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), 2022–2024 data, compiled by TrustAnalytica. FARS covers crashes in which at least one person died; injury-only crashes are not included.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Starting price | Phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Towey Law, PLLC | 4.9 | 23 | — | — | Visit |
| 2 | William Mattar Law Offices | 4.9 | 411 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 444-4444 | Visit |
| 3 | Cellino Law Accident Attorneys | 4.8 | 100 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 714-0464 | Visit |
| 4 | The Law Office of John V. Elmore, P.C. | 4.9 | 59 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 300-0000 | Visit |
| 5 | Morgan & Morgan | 4.8 | 41 | — | (716) 293-5028 | Visit |
| 6 | Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law | 4.7 | 38 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 350-0600 | Visit |
| 7 | Brown Chiari LLP | 3.5 | 48 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 681-7190 | Visit |
| 8 | Mazzu Law PLLC | 5.0 | 32 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 321-1111 | Visit |
| 9 | The Coppola Firm | 4.9 | 32 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 839-9700 | Visit |
| 10 | Nicotra Richard A | 5.0 | 30 | No Win, No Fee | (716) 333-3000 | Visit |
About this Car Accident Settlement Calculator
This calculator uses the multiplier method, the starting point most insurance adjusters and personal injury lawyers use. It adds your financial losses (medical bills and lost wages) to a pain-and-suffering figure, which is those losses multiplied by a factor set by how serious the injury is: 1.5 to 2 times for minor injuries, up to 4 to 5 times for catastrophic ones. The type of accident adjusts the result, and it is then reduced by your share of fault under New York law. In New York, a no-fault state, it also separates what your own PIP insurance pays from what you can claim from the other driver.
New York rules this calculator applies
- Fault rule
- Pure comparative fault. Your payout drops by your share of fault, but you can still recover even if you were mostly at fault.
- Deadline to file
- You generally have 3 years from the date of the injury to file a personal injury claim in New York. Claims against a government body usually need formal notice much sooner, and medical malpractice and wrongful death claims can have their own deadlines.
- No-fault
- Yes. Your own PIP pays first; see below.
No-fault insurance in New York
New York is a no-fault state. After a car accident, your own personal injury protection (PIP) pays your medical bills and 80% of your lost income, up to $50,000, whoever caused the crash.
You can claim pain and suffering from the at-fault driver only if your injury meets New York's serious-injury threshold: a fracture, significant disfigurement, permanent loss or limitation of a body organ, member or function, significant limitation of a body function, or death. Financial losses above your PIP limit can still be claimed.
Since May 26, 2026, a driver who is more than 50% at fault for a car accident in New York can no longer recover pain and suffering, only a reduced share of their financial losses.
Motorcycle riders are generally outside PIP and follow the ordinary fault rules. Choose Motorcycle Accident in the calculator above to see that estimate.
General information about New York law, not legal advice, and the estimate is not a guarantee of any outcome. A lawyer can tell you how these rules apply to your case.
Frequently asked questions
8 questionsHow is my car accident settlement calculated in Buffalo?
What affects my car accident settlement amount in New York?
How is pain and suffering calculated for a Buffalo car accident?
What is the statute of limitations for car accident claims in New York?
Should I accept the insurer's first settlement offer?
How long does it take to settle a car accident claim in Buffalo?
What medical documentation is important for my claim?
How do lawyer fees impact my car accident settlement?
General information, not legal advice — consult a licensed New York attorney.