×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Best Personal Injury Lawyers
  3. Personal Injury Lawyers in New York
  4. Lancaster

Best Personal Injury Lawyers in Lancaster

2 in Lancaster · 19 nearby
Lancaster Personal Injury Lawyers stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
2 +19 nearby
Average rating
4.6 27 reviews
Typical service price
No win, no fee Free consultation, paid only if you win
Most-offered services
Real Estate LawLegal ConsultationProperty Dispute ResolutionPersonal Injury RepresentationInsurance Claims & Settlement
What customers praise
recommend×7highly recommend×3highly recommended×2recommended×2
Personal injury lawyerLancaster, NY

1

The Law Office of Gary M. Schaff

The Law Office of Gary M. Schaff focuses on personal injury, estate planning, and family law with a strong emphasis on personalized service and community values. The team offers clear communication and tailored legal strategies, though some clients have noted occasional delays in responsiveness. Overall, the firm provides accessible legal support rooted in local experience.

Services & Prices
Home Purchase Assistance No Win, No Fee
Home Sale Assistance Free Consultation
Lease Agreements No Fees Unless We Win
Initial Consultation Free Consultation
View Profile
(716) 685-4636
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
33 Central Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
General Services
Real Estate Law
2

Tiveron Law PLLC

Tiveron Law PLLC specializes in personal injury and a range of other legal areas, offering personalized strategies tailored to each client’s needs. Their team handles cases with clear communication and timely responses, and clients often note their professionalism and courteous service. Some find their responsiveness especially helpful during complex legal matters.

Services & Prices
Personal Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Medical Bills & Lost Wages Recovery No Win, No Fee
Insurance Claim Handling No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 636-7600
Open 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
43 Central Ave Suite 1, Lancaster, NY 14086, USA
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
3

Towey Law, PLLC

Serves Lancaster, NY
Verified

Towey Law, PLLC focuses on injury cases involving slip and fall accidents and medical malpractice, helping clients secure compensation for serious injuries. The team handles complex claims and stays in close contact throughout the process, though some cases can be challenging due to medical and insurance complexities. Clients appreciate their clear communication and persistent support.

Services & Prices
Auto Injury Cases, Medical Malpractice, Slip and Fall Cases)
Insurance Negotiation, Claim Filing, Appeals Process)
View Profile
Open 00:00 - 23:59
403 Main St Suite #715, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA
General Services
Personal Injury Law
Injury claim costs by body part

What does an injury cost by body part?

Pick how serious the injury is. Each point shows the average medical bill for that body part at that severity; bigger point = costlier injury. Tap a point to compare it with the average workers’ comp claim for the same body part, which also pays lost wages.

  • Head & brain
  • Neck
  • Back & spine
  • Multiple injuries
FrontBack
smaller claims larger claims
  • Chest, abdomen & hips
  • Arms, hands & shoulders
  • Legs, knees & feet
Sources: Peterson, Xu & Florence, “Average medical cost of fatal and non-fatal injuries by type in the USA”, Injury Prevention 2021 (CDC) — 12-month medical cost after an ER visit, by body region and injury type, 2015 dollars. Workers’ comp claim averages: NCCI (National Council on Compensation Insurance) Injury Characteristics & Insights — average total cost of a lost-time workers’ comp claim (medical bills plus lost-wage payments), all severities combined, policy year 2022. Medical bills only: an injury claim can also include lost wages and pain and suffering.
4

Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law

Serves Lancaster, NY

Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law focuses on helping clients navigate disability claims and personal injury cases, often handling complex paperwork and medical records. The team supports clients through every step, providing timely communication and persistent advocacy, though some find the process naturally overwhelming.

Services & Prices
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Medical Bills & Lost Wages Recovery No Win, No Fee
Settlement Negotiation No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 473-1848
Open 00:00 - 23:59
6000 N Bailey Ave Suite 1A, Amherst, NY 14226
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
5

William Mattar Law Offices

Serves Lancaster, NY

William Mattar P.C. specializes in handling serious truck accident injury claims with a 24/7 legal team ready to respond promptly. They assist clients through every step of the process, gathering evidence and pursuing compensation for injuries. Clients appreciate the team’s respectful communication and consistent updates throughout often lengthy cases.

Services & Prices
18-Wheeler Accident Claims No Win, No Fee
Commercial Truck Liability No Win, No Fee
Trucking Company Investigations No Win, No Fee
Medical Malpractice Representation No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 444-4444
Open 00:00 - 23:59
69 Delaware Ave Suite 1111, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA
General Services
Truck Accident Representation
Where they are 21 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Cellino Law Injury Attorneys

Serves Lancaster, NY

Cellino Law Injury Attorneys focuses on personal injury cases, helping clients navigate claims after accidents. The team handles various injury matters and is often noted for clear communication and responsiveness throughout the process. Some clients mention occasional delays but appreciate the attentive support they receive.

Services & Prices
Slip and Fall Cases No Win, No Fee
Premises Liability Cases No Win, No Fee
Property Owner Negligence No Win, No Fee
Workplace Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 354-8370
Open 00:00 - 23:59
5477 Main St, Amherst, NY 14221
General Services
Slip and Fall & Premises Liability
7

Brandon J. Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law

Serves Lancaster, NY

Specializing in personal injury cases, this firm offers clear guidance through often complex legal processes. The team handles client intake efficiently while maintaining a patient and respectful approach, which many find helpful during stressful times. Some clients note the intake process moves quickly, but the staff remains attentive and supportive throughout.

Services & Prices
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Medical Bills & Lost Wages Recovery No Win, No Fee
Insurance Claim Handling No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(866) 623-5232
Open 00:00 - 23:59
2355 Union Rd #200b, Cheektowaga, NY 14227
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
8

The Law Office of John V. Elmore, P.C.

Serves Lancaster, NY

With more than 35 years of experience, this firm focuses on serious injuries and wrongful death claims involving truck accidents, where federal and state regulations often come into play. The team handles cases with care and keeps clients informed throughout the process, though some have noted occasional communication challenges.

Services & Prices
18-Wheeler Accident Claims No Win, No Fee
Commercial Truck Liability No Win, No Fee
Trucking Company Investigations No Win, No Fee
Medical Malpractice Cases No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 300-0000
Open 8:30 AM - 4:30 PM
2969 Main St Suite 200, Buffalo, NY 14214, USA
General Services
Truck Accident Representation
9

Connors & Ferris, LLP

Serves Lancaster, NY

Connors & Ferris, LLP focuses on personal injury and workers' compensation cases, aiming to guide clients through complex legal processes. The team handles claims with regular updates and clear communication, though some clients have noted occasional delays in returning calls. Overall, they provide support that many find helpful during difficult times.

Services & Prices
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Medical Bills & Lost Wages Recovery No Win, No Fee
Insurance Claim Handling No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 684-2667
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
2570 Walden Ave, Cheektowaga, NY 14225
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
10

Cimasi Law Office

Serves Lancaster, NY

Cimasi Law Office focuses on personal injury and traffic-related cases, offering clear communication and prompt responses that clients appreciate. The team handles court representation and legal advice with professionalism, though some clients have noted inconsistent experiences depending on the case. Many find their responsiveness especially helpful, even when managing matters from a distance.

Services & Prices
Slip and Fall No Win, No Fee
Premises Liability Cases No Win, No Fee
Property Owner Negligence No Win, No Fee
Medical Malpractice No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 267-6430
Open 00:00 - 23:59
66 Park Cir, Amherst, NY 14226
General Services
Slip and Fall & Premises Liability
11

Morgan & Morgan

Serves Lancaster, NY

Morgan & Morgan focuses on personal injury cases, providing legal support to those seeking compensation. The team handles various injury claims and is appreciated for their attentive service. Some clients note communication can be slow at times, but overall, the firm is seen as reliable in representing personal injury matters.

View Profile
(716) 293-5028
Open 00:00 - 23:59
50 Fountain Plz Offices 1411, 1447, & 1450, Buffalo, NY 14202
12

Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law

Serves Lancaster, NY

Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law focus on Social Security Disability and workers’ compensation cases, helping clients navigate complex claims with experienced legal support. Their team is known for clear communication and steady guidance, though some clients note delays and challenges in benefit adjustments during long cases.

Services & Prices
Workplace Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Workers' Comp Benefit Claims No Win, No Fee
Denied Claim Appeals No Win, No Fee
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 350-0600
Open 00:00 - 23:59
424 Main St Suite 1725, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA
General Services
Workers' Compensation Claims
13

Law Office of Robert Berkun

Serves Lancaster, NY

With over 30 years of experience, the Law Office of Robert Berkun focuses on personal injury cases like slip and fall, auto accidents, and medical malpractice. The team handles case evaluation, negotiation, and litigation, often praised for thorough communication and strong advocacy, though some clients note mixed experiences with the lead attorney.

Services & Prices
Slip and Fall Cases No Win, No Fee
Premises Liability Cases No Win, No Fee
Property Owner Negligence No Win, No Fee
Negligence Cases No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 855-3255
Open 00:00 - 23:59
501 John James Audubon Pkwy, Amherst, NY 14228
General Services
Slip and Fall & Premises Liability
14

Losi & Gangi: Jeffrey D. Gangi

Serves Lancaster, NY

Losi & Gangi focuses on serious personal injury cases, including auto, workplace, and construction accidents. The team handles each case with individualized attention and strives to keep clients informed, though some clients note delays in communication. Many appreciate their knowledge and dedication to workers’ compensation claims.

Services & Prices
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Medical Bills & Lost Wages Recovery No Win, No Fee
Settlement Negotiation No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 854-1446
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
147 Linwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14209, USA
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
15

Richmond Vona, LLC

Serves Lancaster, NY

Richmond Vona, LLC focuses on personal injury cases, including boating and motor vehicle accidents, with an emphasis on clear communication and client care. The team handles claims involving negligence, asbestos, and wrongful death, keeping clients informed throughout the process. Clients appreciate their compassion and consistent updates, though some cases may require patience due to complexity.

Services & Prices
Car Accident Cases No Win, No Fee
Car Accident Claims No Win, No Fee
Rear-End Collision Claims No Win, No Fee
Slip and Fall Cases No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 500-5678
Open 00:00 - 23:59
6400 Main St # 130, Williamsville, NY 14221, USA
General Services
Car Accident Representation
16

The Barnes Firm Injury Attorneys

Serves Lancaster, NY

The Barnes Firm Injury Attorneys focus on personal injury cases, including motorcycle accidents, with a contingency-fee policy that keeps clients involved in shaping their legal strategy. Their team handles everything from initial evaluations to settlements, and clients often appreciate their thorough communication, though some find phone contact less personable.

Services & Prices
Auto Accident Cases No Win, No Fee
Car Accident Claims No Win, No Fee
Rear-End Collision Claims No Win, No Fee
Motorcycle Crash Claims No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 274-7803
Open 00:00 - 23:59
451 Grider St, Buffalo, NY 14215, USA
General Services
Car Accident Representation
17

John J. Fromen, Attorneys at Law, PC

Serves Lancaster, NY

Known for handling personal injury cases on a contingency fee basis, John J. Fromen, Attorneys at Law, PC offers personalized attention and legal guidance throughout the process. The team provides knowledgeable and professional service, though some clients note communication could be more consistent during case updates.

Services & Prices
Medical Malpractice No Win, No Fee
Personal Injury Claims No Win, No Fee
Serious Injury Cases No Win, No Fee
Workers' Compensation No Win, No Fee
View Profile
(716) 855-1222
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
4367 Harlem Rd, Buffalo, NY 14226, USA
General Services
Personal Injury Representation
18

Letro Francis M Attorney

Serves Lancaster, NY

Specializing exclusively in severe personal injury and fatal accident cases, Letro Francis M Attorney brings over 30 years of experience to complex claims involving vehicles, defective products, and medical malpractice. The team is known for thorough, compassionate support throughout the legal process, though some clients note the firm’s detailed approach can take time.

View Profile
(716) 852-1234
Open 8:30 AM - 5:30 PM
The Marin Building, 237 Main St Suite 302, Buffalo, NY 14203, USA
19

Donohue Barry J

Serves Lancaster, NY

The Donohue Barry J law firm is recognized as one of the top ten law firms for excellent client service and legal representation. Clients praise the firm for its dedication and sophisticated legal services, with Barry Donohue and his team as devoted clients. Clients find the law firm's excellent client service, reasonable fees, and customized solution to be helpful. All clients comment, which… more...

The Donohue Barry J law firm is recognized as one of the top ten law firms for excellent client service and legal representation. Clients praise the firm for its dedication and sophisticated legal services, with Barry Donohue and his team as devoted clients. Clients find the law firm's excellent client service, reasonable fees, and customized solution to be helpful. All clients comment, which shows that Barry Donohue always cares. Reviewers also praise the legal firm's friendly team and customized options. Clients regard their relationships as significant. Clients clearly approve of Barry Donohue’s law services.

View Profile
(716) 693-0359
Closed Now
77 Broad St, Tonawanda, NY 14150
20

The Fitzgerald Firm, P.C.

Serves Lancaster, NY

With over 40 years of experience, this firm focuses on personal injury cases involving medical negligence and serious accidents. They assist clients injured by medical professionals, vehicle crashes, construction incidents, and more, while also handling insurance claim defenses. Clients appreciate being kept informed, though some note challenges in case follow-up.

View Profile
(716) 852-2000
Open 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
424 Main Street, 509, Liberty Building, Buffalo, NY 14202, USA
21

Donohue David

Serves Lancaster, NY

About Donohue LawDonohue Law has over 108 years of combined legal experience, specializing in personal injury cases. The firm emphasizes personalized client service, with attorneys personally speaking to clients and returning calls promptly. Their mission is to provide dedicated legal representation to individuals suffering serious injuries, ensuring they receive the compensation they deserve.… more...

About Donohue LawDonohue Law has over 108 years of combined legal experience, specializing in personal injury cases. The firm emphasizes personalized client service, with attorneys personally speaking to clients and returning calls promptly. Their mission is to provide dedicated legal representation to individuals suffering serious injuries, ensuring they receive the compensation they deserve. The team’s expertise spans various injury types, including car accidents and medical negligence, setting them apart through their commitment to client advocacy and thorough case handling. The firm’s values focus on integrity, professionalism, and community involvement, making them a trusted choice in Tonawanda, NY.CredibilityThe firm boasts numerous years of experience, with a history dating back to 1973. Their attorneys are highly qualified, with extensive knowledge in personal injury law, and the firm has recovered tens of millions of dollars for clients. Donohue Law is recognized for its dedication to client success, maintaining high customer ratings and memberships in professional legal organizations. Certifications and awards further establish their credibility, and their longstanding presence in the community underscores their reputation for trustworthy legal representation.OfferingsDonohue Law offers comprehensive legal services primarily focused on personal injury law, including car accidents, medical negligence, and civil litigation. They serve clients in Tonawanda and surrounding areas, providing expert legal advice, case evaluation, and representation in court. The firm handles all aspects of injury claims, from initial consultation to settlement or trial, ensuring clients receive personalized attention and strategic advocacy. Their process emphasizes thorough investigation, clear communication, and maximizing compensation for clients’ injuries and damages.Unique AdvantagesThe firm’s key differentiators include over four decades of experience, a team of attorneys with extensive personal injury expertise, and a proven track record of successful case recoveries. Their commitment to personalized service, including direct attorney-client communication, and their deep roots in the Tonawanda community, highlight their dedication. Additionally, their focus on client success and community involvement distinguishes them from competitors, making them a reliable choice for legal representation in personal injury cases.

View Profile
(716) 433-3454
Closed Now
77 Broad St, Tonawanda, NY 14150

Lancaster Traffic Crash Statistics

All fatal traffic crashes in Lancaster, NY, 2024 (latest federal data)

In 2024, 2 people died in 2 fatal traffic crashes in Lancaster, NY (1 in 2023), according to NHTSA’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS).

Traffic deaths
21 in 2023
Fatal crashes
21 in 2023
2022–2024 total
5people killed
Pedestrians killed
0in the city
Roads with the most of these crashes
SR-33

Source: NHTSA Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS), 2022–2024 data, compiled by TrustAnalytica. FARS covers crashes in which at least one person died; injury-only crashes are not included.

Lancaster Personal Injury Lawyers stats: 21 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 The Law Office of Gary M. Schaff 4.5 21 No Win, No Fee (716) 685-4636 Visit
2 Tiveron Law PLLC 4.7 6 No Win, No Fee (716) 636-7600 Visit
3 Towey Law, PLLC 4.9 23 — — Visit
4 Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law 4.6 449 No Win, No Fee (716) 473-1848 Visit
5 William Mattar Law Offices 4.9 411 No Win, No Fee (716) 444-4444 Visit
6 Cellino Law Injury Attorneys 5.0 150 No Win, No Fee (716) 354-8370 Visit
7 Brandon J. Broderick, Personal Injury Attorney at Law 4.9 62 No Win, No Fee (866) 623-5232 Visit
8 The Law Office of John V. Elmore, P.C. 4.9 59 No Win, No Fee (716) 300-0000 Visit
9 Connors & Ferris, LLP 4.5 62 No Win, No Fee (716) 684-2667 Visit
10 Cimasi Law Office 4.8 50 No Win, No Fee (716) 267-6430 Visit
11 Morgan & Morgan 4.8 41 — (716) 293-5028 Visit
12 Hurwitz Whitcher & Molloy Attorneys at Law 4.7 38 No Win, No Fee (716) 350-0600 Visit
13 Law Office of Robert Berkun 4.2 38 No Win, No Fee (716) 855-3255 Visit
14 Losi & Gangi: Jeffrey D. Gangi 3.6 36 No Win, No Fee (716) 854-1446 Visit
15 Richmond Vona, LLC 5.0 18 No Win, No Fee (716) 500-5678 Visit
16 The Barnes Firm Injury Attorneys 4.4 19 No Win, No Fee (716) 274-7803 Visit
17 John J. Fromen, Attorneys at Law, PC 4.3 18 No Win, No Fee (716) 855-1222 Visit
18 Letro Francis M Attorney 4.2 5 — (716) 852-1234 Visit
19 Donohue Barry J 5.0 4 — (716) 693-0359 —
20 The Fitzgerald Firm, P.C. 2.7 6 — (716) 852-2000 Visit
21 Donohue David 5.0 1 — (716) 433-3454 Visit

Frequently asked questions

7 questions
How much do personal injury lawyers in Lancaster charge?
Personal injury lawyers often work on a contingency fee basis, typically around 33% of the settlement. This means they only get paid if you win your case.
How do I choose the best personal injury lawyer in Lancaster?
Consider verified reviews, ratings, and whether the lawyer has claimed their profile. TrustAnalytica ranks based on these factors for a data-driven selection.
What questions should I ask a personal injury lawyer before hiring?
Ask about their experience with similar cases, fee structure, and success rate. Inquire about their communication style and who will handle your case.
Do personal injury lawyers in Lancaster offer free consultations?
Yes, many personal injury lawyers offer free consultations to discuss your case and determine if they can assist you.
What does a personal injury lawyer do?
They handle cases involving injuries from accidents, negotiate with insurance companies, and represent clients in court to seek compensation.
Do I need a personal injury lawyer in New York?
If you've suffered an injury due to someone else's negligence, a lawyer can help navigate legal processes and seek compensation.
How long does a personal injury case take in New York?
The duration varies; cases can take months to years, depending on complexity and whether a settlement is reached or a trial is necessary.

General information, not legal advice — consult a licensed New York attorney.

Our Methodology

Best 10 personal injury lawyer list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Lancaster is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing personal injury lawyer companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 personal injury lawyer category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified personal injury lawyer listings in Lancaster are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive personal injury lawyer profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Lancaster.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our personal injury lawyer rankings in Lancaster, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top personal injury lawyer providers in Lancaster.

5

AI Search Visibility

Every personal injury lawyer listing in Lancaster is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.