Top Auto Insurance Agencies In New York
- Businesses listed
- 5
- Typical service price
- $20 – $40 Median of 9 priced services
- Most-offered services
- Claims AssistanceCustomer SupportInsurance ServicesTravel InsuranceCar Insurance
- What customers praise
- recommend×4highly recommend×4good service×2great service×2
Silver Lining Insurance Agency, Inc.
Silver Lining Insurance Agency, Inc. offers personalized insurance and risk management solutions for individuals, families, and businesses nationwide. The team provides a range of coverage options and is known for professional, empathetic service that helps clients navigate claims and payment challenges. Customers appreciate their responsiveness and thoughtful guidance.
national union auto insurance company
National Union Fire Insurance Company operates as a subsidiary of AIG, offering vehicle and travel insurance policies. Customers often find the claims process difficult and report poor communication, with strict deadlines and documentation requirements. The team provides standard coverage but may not meet expectations for responsive service.
Sarvis Insurance Agency, Inc.
Sarvis Insurance Agency partners with multiple providers to offer reliable insurance options tailored to families and businesses in New York and New Jersey. The agents focus on clear explanations and guiding clients through their coverage choices. Customers appreciate their knowledgeable, personable approach and year-round availability.
Steadfast Insurance Brokerage
Steadfast Insurance Brokerage offers quick vehicle insurance quotes, aiming to provide personalized coverage options. The team handles various auto insurance needs, though some customers find their communication inconsistent. While a few appreciate the affordability and support after accidents, others mention challenges with customer service responsiveness.
RSN Insurance Agency
The best insurance broker in New York is RSN Insurance. Whether you need auto, house, or life insurance, you can rely on us to put out the effort necessary to provide you with a competitive quotation that takes into account all the discounts for which you are eligible.
New York Vehicle Statistics
Vehicles and driving in New York, NY, 2020–2024 (latest Census data)Households in New York, NY own 2,052,185 vehicles — 0.62 per household, compared with 1.25 across New York, according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s American Community Survey (2020–2024). 26% of workers drive to work (average commute 40.3 minutes), and 55% of households have no car. In 2024, 39 people died in 34 fatal crashes in the city (NHTSA FARS).
- Vehicles per household
- 0.62NY 1.25
- Vehicles owned
- 2,052,185by residents
- Drive to work
- 26%NY 55%
- Commutes of 45+ minutes
- 41%of commuters
- Drive alone / carpool
- 22% · 4% of workers
- Average commute
- 40.3 minutes (NY 32.6)
- Public transit / work from home
- 44% · 17%
- Median household income
- $80,483 (NY $85,974)
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates, 2020–2024 data (tables B08201, B25046, B25044, B08301, B08303, B08013, B19013), compiled by TrustAnalytica. Figures are survey estimates with margins of error.
| # | Business | Rating | Reviews | Starting price | Phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Silver Lining Insurance Agency, Inc. | 4.3 | 12 | $10 | — | Visit |
| 2 | national union auto insurance company | 1.4 | 22 | $5 | (212) 770-7000 | Visit |
| 3 | Sarvis Insurance Agency, Inc. | 5.0 | 6 | — | (212) 690-2571 | Visit |
| 4 | Steadfast Insurance Brokerage | 3.0 | 8 | $30 | (212) 233-8258 | Visit |
| 5 | RSN Insurance Agency | 5.0 | 3 | — | (212) 904-1044 | Visit |
Frequently asked questions
8 questionsHow do I choose the best auto insurance agency in New York?
What services do auto insurance agencies provide?
Are free consultations common with auto insurance agencies?
What questions should I ask an auto insurance agency before hiring?
Do I need an auto insurance agency in New York?
How long does it take to get auto insurance in New York?
What are the typical fees for auto insurance agencies?
How do auto insurance agencies in New York help with claims?
General information, not financial advice — consult a qualified professional.
Our Methodology
Best 10 auto insurance agency list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for New York is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.
We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).
Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.
Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.
TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing auto insurance agency companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 auto insurance agency category.
The Process
Business Verification
Verified auto insurance agency listings in New York are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.
Business Details
Comprehensive auto insurance agency profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in New York.
Reviews And Ratings
Real-time customer ratings guide our auto insurance agency rankings in New York, reflecting genuine reputation.
SEO And Keywords
Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top auto insurance agency providers in New York.
AI Search Visibility
Every auto insurance agency listing in New York is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.