×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Best Criminal Lawyers
  3. Criminal Lawyers in New York
  4. Utica

Best Criminal Lawyers In Utica

6 in Utica · 4 nearby
Utica Criminal Lawyers stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
6 +4 nearby
Average rating
4.8 194 reviews
Typical service price
$300 – $600 Median of 9 priced services
Most-offered services
Legal ConsultationMediation ServicesDivorce MediationDivorce RepresentationChild Custody Mediation
What customers praise
recommend×68highly recommend×39very knowledgeable×11very helpful×8
Also serving Utica
Rome4 · 22 km
Criminal law attorneyUtica, NY

1

The Law Offices of Michael N. Kalil

The Law Offices of Michael N. Kalil is among the top ten firms as a result of exceptional client service, clear communication, and professionalism. Reviews consistently praise Mike’s straightforward approach, responsiveness, and expert handling of challenging situations. Clients always note how knowledgeable and supportive he and his staff are, with Ann's responsiveness especially noteworthy.… more...

The Law Offices of Michael N. Kalil is among the top ten firms as a result of exceptional client service, clear communication, and professionalism. Reviews consistently praise Mike’s straightforward approach, responsiveness, and expert handling of challenging situations. Clients always note how knowledgeable and supportive he and his staff are, with Ann's responsiveness especially noteworthy. Another individual shares that Mike's expertise, empathy, and mediation skills transformed a complicated situation into a positive outcome, and many others echo this sentiment. Some reviews contain grudgingly negative client ratings. Additionally, Mike's advice to follow up with him if things seem weird is not for everyone. Reviews are overwhelmingly favorable, describing Michael's practice in every review as a well-managed, ethical, and kind organization.

Services & Prices
Divorce Mediation $150 - $300
Family Mediation $100 - $250
Child Custody Mediation $120 - $250
Initial Consultation $75 - $150
View Profile
(315) 235-1012
Closed Now
1602 Sunset Ave, Utica, NY 13502
General Services
Mediation Services
2

Christopher Jude Pelli, Esq. PLLC

Christopher Jude Pelli, Esq. PLLC, a top-rated Utica law firm, has a long history of victory and happy clients. The company has a strong reputation due to its committed, individualized service and various legal services. Mr. Pelli's high-quality representation and commitment to ethical practice are prominent features of his service. He has succeeded in numerous personal injury and criminal cases… more...

Christopher Jude Pelli, Esq. PLLC, a top-rated Utica law firm, has a long history of victory and happy clients. The company has a strong reputation due to its committed, individualized service and various legal services. Mr. Pelli's high-quality representation and commitment to ethical practice are prominent features of his service. He has succeeded in numerous personal injury and criminal cases, with extensive courtroom experience and a client-centered, strategic approach. Mr. Pelli's clients warmly receive Mr. Pelli's accessible, empathetic, and transparent behavior. His understanding of the law and his passion for justice have continuously resulted in excellent outcomes for the case. These qualities help him to rank amongst the top 10 lawyers in the region.

Services & Prices
Felony Defense $1500 - $5000
Misdemeanor Defense $500 - $1500
Traffic Violations $100 - $400
Initial Case Evaluation $100 - $300
View Profile
(315) 733-3271
Closed Now
3 Derbyshire Pl, Utica, NY 13501
General Services
Criminal Defense
3

Di Giorgio Jr Peter J

Peter J. Di Giorgio Jr. is among the top 10 lawyers for being a reliable expert with emotional and moral integrity. He consistently ranks favorably in client ratings and surveys because he is professional, punctual, and genuinely empathetic. These people find he is skilled at helping them with sensitive matters, especially those that involve a trust or are complicated. Di Giorgio Jr., unlike… more...

Peter J. Di Giorgio Jr. is among the top 10 lawyers for being a reliable expert with emotional and moral integrity. He consistently ranks favorably in client ratings and surveys because he is professional, punctual, and genuinely empathetic. These people find he is skilled at helping them with sensitive matters, especially those that involve a trust or are complicated. Di Giorgio Jr., unlike others, will never treat them like a number or give them the runaround. He is simple and honest. Besides, he will get the results you deserve and require. A good attorney where everyone wins.

View Profile
(315) 738-7101
Closed Now
2103 Genesee St, Utica, NY 13501
4

Kowalczyk & Deery LLP

Kowalczyk & Deery LLP is consistently featured in the top ten best New York real estate attorneys due to Kowalczyk & Deery LLP's professionalism and steadfast ethics. Clients are impressed by the attorneys when it comes to serving their best interests, even if it means delivering hard truths. The reviews discuss their ability to give sound legal advice. Kowalczyk & Deery LLP's dedication to… more...

Kowalczyk & Deery LLP is consistently featured in the top ten best New York real estate attorneys due to Kowalczyk & Deery LLP's professionalism and steadfast ethics. Clients are impressed by the attorneys when it comes to serving their best interests, even if it means delivering hard truths. The reviews discuss their ability to give sound legal advice. Kowalczyk & Deery LLP's dedication to obtaining the best outcomes for clients has led to long-term client relationships that span decades. Kowalczyk & Deery LLP has earned that trust and has developed a strong reputation for quality services.

View Profile
(315) 724-3164
Closed Now
185 Genesee St Ste 12, Utica, NY 13501
5

Festine Armond J

View Profile
(315) 735-7900
Closed Now
258 Genesee St # 603, Utica, NY 13502
Where they are 10 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Randy J Schaal Attorney at Law Utica

About Randy J. Schaal Attorney at LawRandy J. Schaal Attorney at Law is a Central New York law firm serving Oneida, Rome, Syracuse, Utica, and surrounding areas. With over 30 years of experience, Randy J. Schaal is a graduate of Oneida High School, Colgate University, and holds a Juris Doctor from Case Western Reserve University. He is a former Assistant District Attorney and Assistant City… more...

About Randy J. Schaal Attorney at LawRandy J. Schaal Attorney at Law is a Central New York law firm serving Oneida, Rome, Syracuse, Utica, and surrounding areas. With over 30 years of experience, Randy J. Schaal is a graduate of Oneida High School, Colgate University, and holds a Juris Doctor from Case Western Reserve University. He is a former Assistant District Attorney and Assistant City Judge, emphasizing his extensive legal background. The firm prioritizes personalized service, with Randy personally handling initial consultations and maintaining direct communication with clients. The firm’s mission is to provide knowledgeable, dedicated legal guidance tailored to individual client needs, setting itself apart through its commitment to client relationships and local expertise.CredentialsRandy J. Schaal has practiced law for over 30 years, demonstrating deep industry expertise. His credentials include a Juris Doctor degree, experience as an Assistant District Attorney, and a former Assistant City Judge. The firm is recognized for its local reputation, with a focus on personalized service and client trust. While specific certifications or awards are not listed, the firm’s longstanding presence and community involvement serve as credibility signals, emphasizing its commitment to quality legal representation in Central New York.OfferingsThe firm offers legal services primarily in areas such as bankruptcy, criminal law, and civil litigation. It serves clients across Central New York, including Oneida, Rome, Syracuse, and Utica. The process involves personalized consultations where Randy Schaal provides expert legal advice, ensuring clients understand their options and the legal process. The firm’s key benefits include experienced legal guidance, local knowledge, and a commitment to client communication. The firm’s focus on face-to-face consultations and ongoing client support highlights its dedication to accessible, effective legal solutions.Unique AdvantagesThe firm’s unique advantages include Randy Schaal’s over 30 years of legal experience, his local roots in Oneida, and his background as a former Assistant District Attorney and Assistant City Judge. These factors provide clients with a combination of extensive legal expertise and community trust. Additionally, the firm’s personalized approach and direct client contact distinguish it from larger, impersonal firms, offering tailored legal strategies and dedicated service.

View Profile
(315) 363-6888
Closed Now
2219 Genesee St, Utica, NY 13501
7

Rapke Law Firm

Serves Utica, NY

Rapke Law Firm is in the top ten list as a trustworthy legal partner like an industry veteran with over 35 years of experience. Their emphasis on individualized service, integrity, and excellent results distinguishes the practice. Attorney David J. Rapke enjoys a solid reputation for competence, professionalism, and fast communication in the legal community and commit to ensuring that clients get… more...

Rapke Law Firm is in the top ten list as a trustworthy legal partner like an industry veteran with over 35 years of experience. Their emphasis on individualized service, integrity, and excellent results distinguishes the practice. Attorney David J. Rapke enjoys a solid reputation for competence, professionalism, and fast communication in the legal community and commit to ensuring that clients get the best advice possible. But every customer review echoes the accuracy of good reputation. The firm's commitment to explaining complicated legal concepts in clear language helps build long-lasting partnerships with clients. Potential clients in Rome, NY, who require help with real estate transactions, estate planning, or business formation seek the Rapke Law Firm because the firm's experience and dedication to client happiness makes it the go-to option.

Services & Prices
Property Purchase Assistance $300 - $500
Property Sale Assistance $300 - $500
Title Search Services $100 - $200
Will Preparation $200 - $300
View Profile
(315) 336-5450
Closed Now
320 N George St, Rome, NY 13440
General Services
Real Estate Transactions
8

Versace Law Office, P.C.

Serves Utica, NY

Versace Law Office, P.C., led by Att. Meade Versace, is in the top ten list due to various positive reviews about its professionalism, expertise, and reliability. Meade Versace caused a seamless experience for clients when representing them in family and real estate matters. Committed to client interests, he supports clients in analyzing their expectations and options. One client noted that… more...

Versace Law Office, P.C., led by Att. Meade Versace, is in the top ten list due to various positive reviews about its professionalism, expertise, and reliability. Meade Versace caused a seamless experience for clients when representing them in family and real estate matters. Committed to client interests, he supports clients in analyzing their expectations and options. One client noted that Versace Law Office is the only one that refuted corrupt lawyer systems in the Utica area. Some reviewers revealed his attention to detail, straightforward approach, and client-centered strategies, resulting in consistent ideal outcomes.

Services & Prices
Child Custody $150 - $300
Divorce Proceedings $500 - $1500
Child Support $100 - $250
Property Purchase $700 - $2000
View Profile
(315) 339-8574
Closed Now
113 Rose Ln, Rome, NY 13440
General Services
Family Law
9

Bowers Keith

Serves Utica, NY

Bowers Keith is listed among the top 10 advisors due to pleasant customer service. The reviews characterize him as an excellent attorney who has helped clients through difficult family law cases like divorce and child support. This prompts clients to consistently trust him for future legal issues. His professionalism and simplicity are crucial client satisfaction factors, essential for clients… more...

Bowers Keith is listed among the top 10 advisors due to pleasant customer service. The reviews characterize him as an excellent attorney who has helped clients through difficult family law cases like divorce and child support. This prompts clients to consistently trust him for future legal issues. His professionalism and simplicity are crucial client satisfaction factors, essential for clients facing complex family legalities. Keith's reliable and straightforward communication and face-to-face meetings establish trust and ensure clients are well-informed and involved in their legal matters. Keith's reviews signify that clients depend on him for essential family law cases, attesting to his qualifications and suitability for a legal advisor.

View Profile
(315) 338-0181
Closed Now
418 Court St,Rome, NY 13440
10

Viviani Law Firm

Serves Utica, NY

Viviani Law Firm is among the top 10 companies because of its professionalism and effectiveness. Several reviews emphasize professionalism, a strong work ethic, and cooperation. The reviewer cites the lawyer's professionalism as the standout quality. He effectively handles tasks that are time-sensitive. This company has many supporters who have had wonderful experiences with them. In that case… more...

Viviani Law Firm is among the top 10 companies because of its professionalism and effectiveness. Several reviews emphasize professionalism, a strong work ethic, and cooperation. The reviewer cites the lawyer's professionalism as the standout quality. He effectively handles tasks that are time-sensitive. This company has many supporters who have had wonderful experiences with them. In that case, they show the lawyer's excellent qualities. Readers must understand that the law firm's exceptional customer service and professionalism have garnered mixed reviews online. Some have experienced challenges with time-sensitive cases or rude staff, while others praise the lawyer's professionalism, dependability, and dedication to their clients. The law firm's ability to deliver results despite its challenges and keep its clients satisfied makes it a top ten firm.

View Profile
(315) 533-7613
Closed Now
220 W Court St, Rome, NY 13440

Utica Crime Statistics

Crimes reported to the Utica Police Department, 2025 (latest FBI data)

The Utica Police Department recorded 288 violent crimes in 2025 — down 15% from 339 in 2024. That is 455 per 100,000 residents — compared with 368 across New York and 329 nationally, according to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program. Police cleared (solved) 44% of violent crimes and 21% of property crimes.

Violent crimes
288▼ 15%339 in 2024
Property crimes
1,892▼ 1%1,908 in 2024
Violent crime rate
455per 100,000 · NY 368
Arrests
1,300▼ 2%1,326 in 2024
Property crime rate
2,990 per 100,000 (NY 1,567)
Most common arrests
Simple assault 326 · Larceny 233 · Vandalism 138
Weapons arrests
17
Drug arrests
57
DUI arrests
24

Source: FBI Crime Data Explorer, Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program, 2025 data as reported by the Utica Police Department, compiled by TrustAnalytica. Counts crimes reported to police; many crimes are never reported.

Utica Criminal Lawyers stats: 10 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 The Law Offices of Michael N. Kalil 4.7 169 $50 (315) 235-1012 Visit
2 Christopher Jude Pelli, Esq. PLLC 4.9 11 $100 (315) 733-3271 Visit
3 Di Giorgio Jr Peter J 4.3 6 — (315) 738-7101 —
4 Kowalczyk & Deery LLP 4.8 4 — (315) 724-3164 Visit
5 Festine Armond J 5.0 3 — (315) 735-7900 —
6 Randy J Schaal Attorney at Law Utica 5.0 1 — (315) 363-6888 Visit
7 Rapke Law Firm 3.8 24 $100 (315) 336-5450 Visit
8 Versace Law Office, P.C. 4.2 13 $100 (315) 339-8574 —
9 Bowers Keith 4.7 9 — (315) 338-0181 —
10 Viviani Law Firm 3.9 7 — (315) 533-7613 —

Frequently asked questions

9 questions
How do I choose the best criminal lawyer in Utica?
Consider verified reviews and ratings on Google and TrustAnalytica. Rankings weigh review volume and if the business claimed its profile.
What services do criminal lawyers in Utica provide?
Criminal lawyers handle defense against charges like DUI, theft, assault, and drug offenses, and guide clients through the legal process.
How much do criminal lawyers in New York typically charge?
Fees vary widely. Some charge hourly rates, others offer flat fees or retainers. Free consultations are common to discuss costs.
Do I need a criminal lawyer for a misdemeanor in Utica?
Hiring a lawyer can help navigate the legal system, even for misdemeanors, to ensure rights are protected and to seek favorable outcomes.
What questions should I ask a criminal lawyer before hiring?
Ask about their experience with similar cases, fee structure, potential outcomes, and who will handle your case day-to-day.
Are free consultations common with criminal lawyers in Utica?
Yes, many criminal lawyers offer free consultations to discuss your case and potential legal strategies before hiring.
How long does a criminal case take to resolve in New York?
The duration varies by case complexity and court schedules, ranging from a few months to over a year.
What are the typical steps in a criminal defense process?
The process includes arrest, arraignment, discovery, plea negotiations, trial, and possibly appeal.
Do criminal lawyers in Utica handle appeals?
Many criminal lawyers offer services for appeals, but confirm with the lawyer if they handle appellate cases.

General information, not legal advice — consult a licensed New York attorney.

Our Methodology

Best 10 criminal law attorney list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Utica is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing criminal law attorney companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 criminal law attorney category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified criminal law attorney listings in Utica are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive criminal law attorney profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Utica.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our criminal law attorney rankings in Utica, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top criminal law attorney providers in Utica.

5

AI Search Visibility

Every criminal law attorney listing in Utica is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.