×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Best Criminal Lawyers
  3. Criminal Lawyers in South Carolina
  4. Sumter

Best Criminal Lawyers In Sumter

Sumter Criminal Lawyers stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
6
Average rating
4.5 129 reviews
Typical service price
$200 – $500 Median of 13 priced services
Most-offered services
Legal ServicesReal Estate ServicesFamily LawCriminal DefenseCivil Law
What customers praise
recommend×26highly recommend×18highly recommended×8very professional×8
Criminal law attorneySumter, SC

1

Held Paul L Law Office

Held Paul L Law Office is a Top 10 ranking law firm in Sumter SC. The firm has dedicated over 25 years of community service and offers affordable legal representation in bankruptcy, family law, and estate planning. The firm’s staff is made up of compassionate attorneys and their reputation for transparent and personalized service is solid. The firm’s commitment to veterans, community involvement… more...

Held Paul L Law Office is a Top 10 ranking law firm in Sumter SC. The firm has dedicated over 25 years of community service and offers affordable legal representation in bankruptcy, family law, and estate planning. The firm’s staff is made up of compassionate attorneys and their reputation for transparent and personalized service is solid. The firm’s commitment to veterans, community involvement, and compassionate approach to clients’ situations has earned positive ratings and reviews from veterans and local residents. You can find out more by visiting http://heldpaulllawoffice.com.

View Profile
(803) 775-6669
Closed Now
136 N Main St, Sumter, SC 29150
2

Keffer Law Firm | Attorney John S. Keffer

Keffer Law Firm | Attorney John S. Keffer is among the top 10 South Carolina law firms due to unparalleled client service, adeptness, and a tailored strategy. The firm is in Sumter, SC, and over a decade, it has specialized in family law, DUI defense, personal injury, and criminal law. Clients frequently commend Mr. Keffer and his team for their friendly demeanor, responsive assistance, and… more...

Keffer Law Firm | Attorney John S. Keffer is among the top 10 South Carolina law firms due to unparalleled client service, adeptness, and a tailored strategy. The firm is in Sumter, SC, and over a decade, it has specialized in family law, DUI defense, personal injury, and criminal law. Clients frequently commend Mr. Keffer and his team for their friendly demeanor, responsive assistance, and clarity in difficult issues; they claim he is adept at making even complicated cases understandable and manageable. The firm’s legal talent, a record of substantial court victories, and a philosophy of dedication to each client have cemented its status as one of South Carolina’s most reputable law organizations.

Services & Prices
Divorce Proceedings $2000 - $5000
Child Custody $1500 - $4000
Adoption Services $3000 - $7000
DUI Defense $1500 - $6000
View Profile
(803) 774-1004
Closed Now
10 Law Range, Sumter, SC 29150
General Services
Family Law
3

McDougall, Self, Currence & McLeod

Top 10 Law Firm: McDougall, Self, Currence & McLeod, PLLC - Sumter - SC. This firm is among Top 10 due to more than 90 years of experience, a devoted team, and community recognition. Their multi-characteristic legal services are particularly valuable for complex family law cases, criminal defense, and personal injuries. Reviews rave on excellent communication, client experience, emotional refuge… more...

Top 10 Law Firm: McDougall, Self, Currence & McLeod, PLLC - Sumter - SC. This firm is among Top 10 due to more than 90 years of experience, a devoted team, and community recognition. Their multi-characteristic legal services are particularly valuable for complex family law cases, criminal defense, and personal injuries. Reviews rave on excellent communication, client experience, emotional refuge, and aggressive representation. For instance, Ryan McLeod’s sharp advocacy, personalization, and response custom design allow a dedicated focus on the case. Their AV Preeminent® peer rating and Super Lawyers designation confirm their high ethical standards.

Services & Prices
Contested Divorce $1500 - $3000
Uncontested Divorce $500 - $1500
Divorce Consultation $100 - $200
Custody Agreement Drafting $300 - $600
View Profile
(803) 778-5062
Closed Now
21 E Calhoun St, Sumter, SC 29150
General Services
Divorce Law
4

Player & McMillan

Player & McMillan is named to the top 10 best list. The firm has some of the best criminal and family law representation. Client praise for Peter McMillan reflects his dedication and skillful representation that spans years. Most reviews indicate that the firm is friendly, helpful, and professional, with several referrals to a staff member. But not all online reviews are favorable, with one… more...

Player & McMillan is named to the top 10 best list. The firm has some of the best criminal and family law representation. Client praise for Peter McMillan reflects his dedication and skillful representation that spans years. Most reviews indicate that the firm is friendly, helpful, and professional, with several referrals to a staff member. But not all online reviews are favorable, with one review accusing the firm of deception and inefficiency. When consistent positive reviews are tallied, Player & McMillan has a top 10 finish for attorney-client relationships and successful outcomes in family and criminal litigation.

Services & Prices
Criminal Defense $150 - $300
Family Law $100 - $250
Divorce Proceedings $200 - $400
Home Purchases $300 - $500
View Profile
(803) 775-2306
Closed Now
305 N Main St, Sumter, SC 29150
General Services
Legal Services
5

Shuler Franklin

Shuler Franklin is listed in the top ten law firm due to their superb client service and skills and expertise in legal representation. The overwhelming majority of reviews indicate that Mr. Shuler and his team consistently offer friendly, professional, and efficient service. Additionally, clients commend Shuler Franklin's ability to handle complex legal tasks, like power of attorney and business… more...

Shuler Franklin is listed in the top ten law firm due to their superb client service and skills and expertise in legal representation. The overwhelming majority of reviews indicate that Mr. Shuler and his team consistently offer friendly, professional, and efficient service. Additionally, clients commend Shuler Franklin's ability to handle complex legal tasks, like power of attorney and business registration. The firm is also described as reliable, with lots of customers coming back for assistance with additional issues. The few critiques about the costs of services are far less frequent than the positive feedback about the firm's dedication, expertise, and client satisfaction.

Services & Prices
Power of Attorney $50 - $150
Business Registration $200 - $500
Real Estate Law $300 - $1000
General Notary $5 - $25
View Profile
(803) 774-8500
Closed Now
1 Law Range, Sumter, SC 29150
General Services
Legal Services
Where they are 6 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Shuler Law Firm

Shuler Law Firm ranks on the top ten of the list because of its excellent client service, brilliant communication, and professionalism, especially from Jake Dippold. Multiple reviewers appreciate Jake's responsiveness, clarity, and beneficial advice, calling him the best communicator they have engaged with. Clients also like that the firm treats their concerns seriously, which guarantees them… more...

Shuler Law Firm ranks on the top ten of the list because of its excellent client service, brilliant communication, and professionalism, especially from Jake Dippold. Multiple reviewers appreciate Jake's responsiveness, clarity, and beneficial advice, calling him the best communicator they have engaged with. Clients also like that the firm treats their concerns seriously, which guarantees them personalized help. The repeated mentions of professionalism and effective communication establish Shuler Law Firm as a reliable and client-focused law practice, making it an attractive choice for anyone looking for strong legal counsel.

View Profile
(803) 774-8500
Closed Now
1 Law Range, Sumter, SC 29150

Sumter Crime Statistics

Crimes reported to the Sumter Police Department, 2025 (latest FBI data)

The Sumter Police Department recorded 304 violent crimes in 2025 — down 35% from 465 in 2024. That is 710 per 100,000 residents — compared with 389 across South Carolina and 329 nationally, according to the FBI’s Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program. Police cleared (solved) 35% of violent crimes and 26% of property crimes.

Violent crimes
304▼ 35%465 in 2024
Property crimes
1,172▼ 26%1,578 in 2024
Violent crime rate
710per 100,000 · SC 389
Arrests
699▼ 7%754 in 2024
Property crime rate
2,736 per 100,000 (SC 1,715)
Most common arrests
Larceny 196 · Drug possession 109 · Simple assault 90
Murder arrests
5
Weapons arrests
13
Drug arrests
141
DUI arrests
26

Source: FBI Crime Data Explorer, Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) program, 2025 data as reported by the Sumter Police Department, compiled by TrustAnalytica. Counts crimes reported to police; many crimes are never reported.

Sumter Criminal Lawyers stats: 6 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 Held Paul L Law Office 4.1 55 — (803) 775-6669 Visit
2 Keffer Law Firm | Attorney John S. Keffer 4.5 29 $1,000 (803) 774-1004 Visit
3 McDougall, Self, Currence & McLeod 4.6 20 $100 (803) 778-5062 Visit
4 Player & McMillan 4.2 11 $100 (803) 775-2306 —
5 Shuler Franklin 4.5 10 $5 (803) 774-8500 Visit
6 Shuler Law Firm 4.8 4 — (803) 774-8500 Visit

Frequently asked questions

8 questions
How do I choose the best criminal lawyer in Sumter?
Consider verified reviews, ratings, review volume, and if the business claims its profile. TrustAnalytica ranks based on these factors for transparency.
What services do criminal lawyers in Sumter offer?
Criminal lawyers handle defense in criminal cases, including DUI, theft, assault, and drug charges. They provide legal representation and advice throughout the legal process.
Are free consultations common with criminal lawyers in Sumter?
Yes, many criminal lawyers offer free initial consultations to discuss the case and potential strategies. Confirm this when contacting a lawyer.
How do criminal lawyers in South Carolina charge fees?
Criminal lawyers typically charge hourly rates or flat fees. Fee structures vary, so discuss costs upfront to understand potential expenses.
What questions should I ask a criminal lawyer before hiring?
Ask about their experience with similar cases, fee structure, strategy for your case, and expected outcomes. Understanding their approach is crucial.
Do I need a criminal lawyer for minor offenses in Sumter?
While not mandatory, having a lawyer can help navigate legal complexities and potentially mitigate consequences, even for minor offenses.
How long does the criminal defense process take in South Carolina?
The timeline varies based on case complexity, court schedules, and plea negotiations. It can range from months to over a year.
Can a criminal lawyer help with expungements in Sumter?
Yes, criminal lawyers can assist with expungement processes, helping to clear eligible criminal records from public view.

General information, not legal advice — consult a licensed South Carolina attorney.

Our Methodology

Best 10 criminal law attorney list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Sumter is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing criminal law attorney companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 criminal law attorney category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified criminal law attorney listings in Sumter are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive criminal law attorney profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Sumter.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our criminal law attorney rankings in Sumter, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top criminal law attorney providers in Sumter.

5

AI Search Visibility

Every criminal law attorney listing in Sumter is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.