×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Top Home Insurance Agencies
  3. Home Insurance Agencies in Wisconsin
  4. Appleton

Top Home Insurance Agencies In Appleton

6 in Appleton · 1 nearby
Appleton Home Insurance Agencies stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
6 +1 nearby
Average rating
4.7 177 reviews
Typical service price
$150 – $200 Median of 16 priced services
Most-offered services
Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceBusiness InsuranceUmbrella Insurance
What customers praise
recommend×30highly recommend×14very helpful×10helped me×6
Also serving Appleton
Green Bay1 · 38 km
Home insurance agencyAppleton, WI

1

Thiel Insurance Group, LLC

Known for personalized insurance recommendations, Thiel Insurance Group, LLC helps customers in the Fox Valley find coverage that balances price and protection. Their team offers home, auto, and other insurance services with clear communication and attentive support. Clients appreciate their responsiveness and thorough guidance, especially during claims.

Services & Prices
Basic Coverage $50 - $100
Comprehensive Coverage $100 - $150
Full Coverage $150 - $250
Basic Home Insurance $300 - $500
View Profile
(920) 739-6241
Closed Now
620 N Richmond St, Appleton, WI 54911, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
2

McHugh Family Insurance

With over 15 years of experience, McHugh Family Insurance helps clients find competitive rates across multiple providers while clearly explaining coverage options. The team offers a range of policies including home, auto, motorcycle, life, and business insurance, and customers appreciate their friendly, knowledgeable service and ongoing support.

Services & Prices
Liability Coverage $50 - $100
Comprehensive Coverage $100 - $200
Collision Coverage $75 - $150
Property Protection $300 - $600
View Profile
(920) 364-9400
Closed Now
1400 N Rankin St, Appleton, WI 54911, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
3

Diedrich Family Insurance

Known for personalized service and quick responses, Diedrich Family Insurance helps clients find coverage for homes, vehicles, and businesses. The team works closely with customers to tailor policies that fit their needs, with many appreciating their thoroughness and willingness to explain details clearly. Some prefer in-person visits over online interactions for a smoother experience.

Services & Prices
Standard Auto Insurance $100 - $200
Comprehensive Auto Insurance $150 - $300
Liability Auto Insurance $80 - $150
Standard Homeowners Insurance $800 - $1500
View Profile
(920) 733-7331
Closed Now
225 N Richmond St #106, Appleton, WI 54911, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
4

Hurley Insurance Services

Hurley Insurance Services specializes in Erie Insurance policies, offering competitive rates and responsive support. The team handles home and auto insurance with quick turnaround times and clear communication. Customers appreciate the smooth transitions and consistent service, though some note the focus is primarily on Erie coverage.

Services & Prices
Full Coverage $100 - $200
Liability Coverage $50 - $150
Collision Coverage $75 - $175
Dwelling Coverage $80 - $180
View Profile
(920) 687-0687
Open 00:00 - 23:59
N365 Rogers Ln, Appleton, WI 54915, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
5

Zuleger Agency - Meemic Insurance Agent

Specializing in home and auto insurance for educators, Zuleger Agency partners with Meemic, a company founded by teachers with over 70 years serving the educational community. The agents offer knowledgeable guidance on coverage options and are known for being friendly and helpful, though some customers have noted communication delays during policy changes.

View Profile
(920) 832-9285
Closed Now
2229 N Richmond St, Appleton, WI 54911, USA
Where they are 7 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Maurer Insurance Agency, LLC

The German name Maurer means "The Wall". Protecting your family and business is our mission. The wall will protect you and your business. The mission of our Insurance Counselors is to protect your family and business from all kinds of disasters. Pay attention to your concerns and needs Ask any questions to help you select the best protection. Create a customized insurance plan that meets your… more...

The German name Maurer means "The Wall". Protecting your family and business is our mission. The wall will protect you and your business. The mission of our Insurance Counselors is to protect your family and business from all kinds of disasters. Pay attention to your concerns and needs Ask any questions to help you select the best protection. Create a customized insurance plan that meets your requirements and your budget Treat you with respect and dignity. Be sure to look out for your interests. We will conduct our business with the utmost honesty and integrity We at Maurer Insurance Agency, LLC are proud to be able to provide the highest level of coverage for you and your family. Our partners are carefully selected to provide exceptional insurance experiences for our clients. You have a busy life and don't have the time or patience to compare prices for coverage. This is what we do. You can be assured that we will work for your best protection with over 20 carriers available. Our passion is to help our clients. We enjoy working with them and believe in their products. Relax and be assured that The Wall is there to help you.

View Profile
(920) 560-5800
Closed Now
2835 W College Ave, Appleton, WI 54914, USA
7

Farmers Insurance - Karen Van Liere-Matuszak

Serves Appleton, WI

With 14 years of experience, this agency focuses on helping clients understand the best coverage options for auto, home, renters, specialty, and life insurance. The agents are known for clear communication and making the insurance process straightforward, though some customers note the need to be proactive for timely responses.

Services & Prices
Comprehensive Coverage $100 - $150
Liability Coverage $75 - $125
Collision Coverage $100 - $200
Dwelling Coverage $700 - $1500
View Profile
(920) 297-2007
Closed Now
2685 W Mason St Ste C, Green Bay, WI 54303, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
Appleton Home Insurance Agencies stats: 7 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 Thiel Insurance Group, LLC 5.0 100 $15 (920) 739-6241 Visit
2 McHugh Family Insurance 4.6 40 $50 (920) 364-9400 Visit
3 Diedrich Family Insurance 4.9 20 $30 (920) 733-7331 Visit
4 Hurley Insurance Services 5.0 7 $20 (920) 687-0687 Visit
5 Zuleger Agency - Meemic Insurance Agent 4.0 7 — (920) 832-9285 Visit
6 Maurer Insurance Agency, LLC 4.7 3 — (920) 560-5800 Visit
7 Farmers Insurance - Karen Van Liere-Matuszak 5.0 23 $5 (920) 297-2007 Visit

Frequently asked questions

8 questions
How do I choose the best home insurance agency in Appleton?
Consider verified reviews, ratings, and if the business has claimed its profile. TrustAnalytica ranks agencies using these factors for a data-driven choice.
What questions should I ask a home insurance agency before hiring?
Ask about coverage options, claim process, discounts, and policy limits. Clarify fees and inquire about customer service availability.
Do home insurance agencies in Appleton offer free consultations?
Many home insurance agencies commonly offer free consultations to discuss coverage needs and options.
What does a home insurance agency do?
Home insurance agencies help clients find suitable policies, provide quotes, and assist with claims and policy management.
How long does it take to get home insurance in Wisconsin?
The process typically takes a few days, depending on the agency's efficiency and the complexity of the coverage required.
Do I need a home insurance agency in Appleton?
While not mandatory, using an agency can simplify finding the right insurance policy and provide expert guidance.
How do home insurance fees work in Appleton?
Fees typically include premiums based on coverage level, property value, and risk factors. Agencies may offer payment plans.
What are common coverage options offered by home insurance agencies?
Common options include dwelling coverage, personal property protection, liability insurance, and additional living expenses coverage.

General information, not financial advice — consult a qualified professional.

Our Methodology

Best 10 home insurance agency list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Appleton is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing home insurance agency companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 home insurance agency category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified home insurance agency listings in Appleton are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive home insurance agency profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Appleton.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our home insurance agency rankings in Appleton, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top home insurance agency providers in Appleton.

5

AI Search Visibility

Every home insurance agency listing in Appleton is published with structured data that AI search tools like ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews can read and cite.