Top Property Management Companies In Wisconsin

Residential Renters specializes in connecting tenants with apartments while helping property owners boost occupancy in the Milwaukee metro area. Their team offers responsive communication and personalized showings, with many renters appreciating the patient, knowledgeable agents who make the process less overwhelming. Some find the volume of options a bit challenging to navigate.

With 30 years of experience managing nearly 5,000 properties, Madison Property Management, Inc. offers full-service rental management with a 24/7 emergency maintenance team. They handle everything from rent collection to property upkeep, though some tenants report delays and communication issues with repairs and customer service.

Top Level Property Management LLC offers 24/7 access to financial and property information through a mobile-friendly portal, making payments and communication straightforward for owners and tenants. They manage a mix of houses and apartments, with many clients appreciating their prompt responses and clear updates, though some have noted concerns about their handling of disputes and feedback.

Blue Frog Property Management offers full-service management and tenant placement tailored to homeowners and landlords. They handle maintenance requests promptly, with a friendly and responsive team, though some tenants note challenges reaching customer service and occasional property upkeep issues. Their rental options include condos, townhouses, and single-family homes.

With over 50 years of experience managing multiple apartment communities, Northland Management LLC offers competitively priced homes with most utilities included. Residents appreciate the attentive maintenance team, ongoing building updates, and friendly office staff, though some note occasional noise from neighbors due to building construction.

Schulhof Properties focuses on providing affordable, well-maintained apartments popular with students and renters seeking convenient locations near UWM. Their team handles maintenance requests promptly and keeps buildings clean, though some tenants have noted occasional issues with responsiveness and accommodations for assistance animals. Customers appreciate the friendly, helpful office staff… more...

Schulhof Properties focuses on providing affordable, well-maintained apartments popular with students and renters seeking convenient locations near UWM. Their team handles maintenance requests promptly and keeps buildings clean, though some tenants have noted occasional issues with responsiveness and accommodations for assistance animals. Customers appreciate the friendly, helpful office staff and overall value.

JEK Property Management, LLC focuses on creating friendly, safe communities with a range of apartments from one-bedroom units to large four-bedroom duplexes, many of which are pet friendly. Their team handles maintenance promptly and provides helpful, communicative management, though some renters note that company policies around touring can feel restrictive.

Known for its personal service since 1977, Wisconsin Management Company handles a wide range of residential properties with a large team of credentialed professionals. They offer leasing, maintenance, and tenant support, though some residents report ongoing repair delays and communication challenges. Many appreciate the attentive staff when issues are addressed.

Jomela Properties specializes in affordable rentals, including single-family homes, apartments, and duplexes throughout Milwaukee. Their team handles leasing and maintenance requests, aiming to assist tenants with property needs. Some tenants note challenges with communication and maintenance responsiveness, while others appreciate the staff’s efforts to provide helpful support.

Prospect Management Company specializes in managing homeowner associations and condominiums across the Greater Milwaukee, Madison, and Kenosha areas. They offer full-service property management, including board meeting support and resident communications. While some residents appreciate the friendly staff and responsiveness, others report issues with maintenance and communication delays.

Wilkins Property Management focuses on creating a pet-friendly, community-oriented living experience with prompt maintenance and management support. They assist residents in finding apartments near dining, shopping, and major highways in the Greater Milwaukee area. While many tenants appreciate the responsive staff and quick repairs, some have noted occasional delays in addressing concerns.

Known for personalized service and over 30 years of experience, Bruner Realty & Management, Inc. offers expertise in home sales, condominium development, and property management. Clients appreciate the team’s responsiveness and guidance through buying, selling, and managing rentals, though a few note occasional communication delays during the rental application process.

Known for quick, friendly responses and well-maintained apartments near UW Madison, Greenbush Properties offers affordable housing with attentive service. The team handles maintenance requests promptly and respects tenant privacy, creating a comfortable living experience. Some renters note the smaller scale means a more personal, hands-on approach.

Day Property Management has been handling rental and property management services since 2002, focusing on single-family, duplex, and multi-family homes across northeastern Wisconsin. They offer full-service management as well as tenant placement, with communication often noted as responsive, though some renters report slow maintenance and strict lease terms.

With over 20 years serving Madison residents, Smith Management focuses on full-service residential property management. Their team handles leasing and maintenance with clear communication and responsiveness, helping renters find and settle into homes smoothly. Some customers note the leasing process can feel quick but appreciate the helpful guidance throughout.

Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro offers 24/7 tenant and emergency maintenance support, helping landlords avoid interruptions during their workday. The team handles tenant-landlord law compliance, Fair Housing, and evictions, while providing property management and leasing services. Some clients appreciate their responsiveness and professionalism, though a few have noted occasional… more...

Real Property Management Greater Madison Metro offers 24/7 tenant and emergency maintenance support, helping landlords avoid interruptions during their workday. The team handles tenant-landlord law compliance, Fair Housing, and evictions, while providing property management and leasing services. Some clients appreciate their responsiveness and professionalism, though a few have noted occasional communication issues.

Structure Properties, LLC focuses on managing individual apartment buildings, townhomes, and single-family homes with a hands-on approach that treats each property like their own. Their team handles maintenance and tenant needs promptly, using an easy online portal for payments and communication. While some find their organization inconsistent, many appreciate the responsive and helpful service.

Known for straightforward fees with no leasing or administrative charges, Dobson Property Management LLC offers full-service management for condos, residential, and commercial properties in Madison and Dane counties. The team handles tenant sourcing, maintenance, and rent collection, with many clients appreciating their responsiveness and care, though some tenants have found communication… more...

Known for straightforward fees with no leasing or administrative charges, Dobson Property Management LLC offers full-service management for condos, residential, and commercial properties in Madison and Dane counties. The team handles tenant sourcing, maintenance, and rent collection, with many clients appreciating their responsiveness and care, though some tenants have found communication occasionally challenging.

Kader Property Management is known for responsive, hands-on service that focuses on tenant satisfaction and well-maintained properties. They handle everything from showings to upkeep, with tenants appreciating their professionalism and quick response to issues. Some renters note minor fees for online payments, but overall the team is described as caring and approachable.

Pfefferle Management focuses on tailored property management services designed to improve cost efficiency and tenant satisfaction. They handle everything from financial oversight to maintenance coordination, often working closely with condo boards to address community needs. While some tenants mention delays in repairs, others appreciate the team’s responsiveness and professionalism.

Specializing in commercial property management and brokerage, J. Ross & Associates focuses on helping clients increase income and net worth through efficient service. Their team handles everything from leasing and sales to Broker Opinion of Value reports, with clients appreciating their professionalism, market knowledge, and timely communication throughout each transaction.

Pennybag Property Management offers a range of services including home repairs, remodeling, and property buying without real estate fees or waiting periods. Their team handles everything from landscaping to plumbing with clear communication and fair pricing. Customers appreciate their professionalism and responsiveness, though the variety of services means scheduling can sometimes be busy.

Known for responsive service and a full-time staff, Main Street Management uses up-to-date technology to support both landlords and tenants in Green Bay. They handle everything from maintenance requests to billing with quick turnaround times, and customers appreciate their attention to detail and reliable communication. Some note occasional delays, but overall the team is seen as attentive and… more...

Known for responsive service and a full-time staff, Main Street Management uses up-to-date technology to support both landlords and tenants in Green Bay. They handle everything from maintenance requests to billing with quick turnaround times, and customers appreciate their attention to detail and reliable communication. Some note occasional delays, but overall the team is seen as attentive and professional.

Performance Asset Management focuses on providing healthy, safe rental homes while helping investors increase their income through digital leasing and maintenance solutions. Their services include full property management, renovations, and asset upkeep, with no extra fees for renewals or vacancies. Some tenants note communication can be limited, but many appreciate the team’s professionalism and… more...

Performance Asset Management focuses on providing healthy, safe rental homes while helping investors increase their income through digital leasing and maintenance solutions. Their services include full property management, renovations, and asset upkeep, with no extra fees for renewals or vacancies. Some tenants note communication can be limited, but many appreciate the team’s professionalism and responsiveness.