Best Engagement Ring Designers In Milwaukee

With over 120 years of experience, Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers specializes in personalized engagement ring design featuring GIA-certified diamonds and a broad selection from reputable manufacturers. Customers appreciate the team’s attentive service and deep knowledge, though some advise caution with heirloom pieces due to past resizing concerns.

Known for its skilled Master Goldsmith and Certified Watchmaker, Harry C. Glinberg Jewelers offers custom engagement rings, diamond jewelry, and watch services. The team is appreciated for their ethical approach and friendly, attentive service, though some customers note the shop’s busy atmosphere.

Known for fast custom CAD jewelry design, J.P. Haase Jewelers creates detailed engagement and wedding rings, often completing pieces within three weeks. The team also handles repairs, sizing, and stone setting, with customers appreciating their fair pricing and attentive service, though some find the process takes a bit of time.

With over 30 years of experience, Barnes Goldsmith Shop focuses on honest craftsmanship and transparent pricing. The family-owned team offers custom engagement ring design and expert goldsmith work, often praised for their fair prices and reliable service. Some customers note the shop’s modest setting compared to larger retailers.

Pak’s Jewelers specializes in custom jewelry creation, guiding customers through every step from design sketches to casting and diamond setting. The team invites clients to witness the detailed manufacturing process firsthand, ensuring transparency and trust. While craftsmanship receives praise, some customers note challenges with communication and order timing.

Known for specializing exclusively in jewelry since 1997, Reflections Jewelry offers custom engagement ring design alongside buying, selling, and pawning services. Customers appreciate the friendly team and careful craftsmanship, though some note pricing can be on the higher side. The staff prefers in-person visits to accurately assess items and provide detailed assistance.

With over 25 years of experience and a Gemological Institute of America background, Rohr Jewelers specializes in custom designs that let the materials guide the creative process. The team works with pearls, precious stones, and diamonds to craft unique engagement rings and wedding bands. While customers appreciate the honest service and artistry, a few note that repairs can sometimes require… more...

With over 25 years of experience and a Gemological Institute of America background, Rohr Jewelers specializes in custom designs that let the materials guide the creative process. The team works with pearls, precious stones, and diamonds to craft unique engagement rings and wedding bands. While customers appreciate the honest service and artistry, a few note that repairs can sometimes require additional visits.

Specializing in custom-made jewelry, Genesis Jewelry & Art Gallery offers personalized engagement ring designs crafted to reflect individual stories. The team also provides repairs and polishing, often accommodating sentimental pieces with care and prompt service. Customers appreciate the friendly, knowledgeable staff and the gallery’s inviting atmosphere.

Mid Continental Gems features a Gemological Institute of America–accredited team known for designing custom engagement rings and resetting heirloom diamonds. They offer competitive pricing on quality gemstones and jewelry, with customers appreciating their honest, friendly service and attention to detail. Some note repairs can take time but find the results worthwhile.

Specializing in custom and semi-custom engagement rings, Custom Bridal Jewelry Inc offers personalized designs that combine various elements to create unique pieces. The team also crafts wedding bands for both ladies and gents, including tungsten options. Customers appreciate the attentive communication and the ability to bring their ideas to life through a smooth, collaborative process.