×

Review Keywords Analysis

  1. United States
  2. Top Auto Insurance Agencies
  3. Auto Insurance Agencies in Ohio
  4. Columbus

Top Auto Insurance Agencies In Columbus

Columbus Auto Insurance Agencies stats: Key insights from this page’s listings Updated
Businesses listed
10
Average rating
4.18 449 reviews
Typical service price
$100 – $200 Median of 29 priced services
Most-offered services
Auto InsuranceHome InsuranceHomeowners InsuranceCustomer ServiceBusiness Insurance
What customers praise
recommend×32highly recommend×16affordable×14great customer service×12

1

Acceptance Insurance

Acceptance Insurance specializes in helping drivers navigate Ohio’s auto insurance requirements, including SR-22 filings and coverage for those with less-than-perfect credit. The local agents provide clear explanations and multiple payment options, with many customers appreciating their professionalism and willingness to find affordable rates. Some note occasional difficulty reaching the office… more...

Acceptance Insurance specializes in helping drivers navigate Ohio’s auto insurance requirements, including SR-22 filings and coverage for those with less-than-perfect credit. The local agents provide clear explanations and multiple payment options, with many customers appreciating their professionalism and willingness to find affordable rates. Some note occasional difficulty reaching the office by phone.

Services & Prices
Basic Coverage $30 - $50
Comprehensive Coverage $100 - $150
SR-22 Filing $20 - $40
Basic Homeowners $200 - $300
View Profile
+16146817926
Open 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM
4651 Morse Centre Rd, Columbus, OH 43229, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
2

Solid Insurance

Licensed agents at Solid Insurance handle the time-consuming process of finding affordable, comprehensive auto coverage, including liability, collision, and medical options. The team guides customers through policies and claims with personal, attentive service, though some note occasional difficulty reaching them by phone. Many appreciate the helpful and friendly support throughout.

Services & Prices
Full Coverage $100 - $200
SR22 Insurance $50 - $150
Liability Insurance $75 - $175
Basic Coverage $300 - $600
View Profile
+16148540000
Open 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM
986 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
3

Progressive Insurance

Progressive Insurance focuses on innovation and transparency, aiming to offer auto and other insurance with a forward-thinking approach. They provide various coverage options but some customers find the purchasing process and claim handling to be time-consuming and occasionally frustrating. The team strives to improve outcomes for both clients and communities.

Services & Prices
Personal Vehicle Insurance $50 - $150
Motorcycle Insurance $40 - $120
Recreational Vehicle Insurance $60 - $200
Dwelling Coverage $600 - $1200
View Profile
+16149043140
Closed Now
3208 Morse Rd #150, Columbus, OH 43231, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
4

Direct Auto Insurance

Direct Auto Insurance focuses on providing non-standard auto insurance for drivers who may be considered high-risk or require SR-22 certification. They offer car and motorcycle coverage, roadside assistance, and flexible payment options without needing a credit or checking account. Customers appreciate the attentive service, though some note a delay before coverage becomes effective.

Services & Prices
Basic Coverage $100 - $150
Comprehensive Coverage $200 - $300
Roadside Assistance $50 - $100
Policy Explanation $0 - $0
View Profile
+16144979500
Open 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM
3783 S High St, Columbus, OH 43207, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
5

A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio

Specializing in minimum required auto insurance and SR22 bonds, Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio offers a range of coverage options including commercial vehicles, motorcycles, renters, and homeowners insurance. The agents work with multiple companies to find competitive rates, and many customers appreciate the affordable pricing and helpful service, though some note occasional communication… more...

Specializing in minimum required auto insurance and SR22 bonds, Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio offers a range of coverage options including commercial vehicles, motorcycles, renters, and homeowners insurance. The agents work with multiple companies to find competitive rates, and many customers appreciate the affordable pricing and helpful service, though some note occasional communication challenges.

Services & Prices
Standard Car Insurance $50 - $100
High Risk Car Insurance $100 - $200
SR22 Car Insurance $60 - $120
Phone Support $0
View Profile
+16142217007
Open 10:00 AM - 1:00 PM
1180 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43222, USA
General Services
Car Insurance
Where they are 10 on the map Click a pin for the profile and directions
6

Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC

Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC is an independent agency offering personalized auto insurance solutions in Columbus and throughout Ohio. The team helps clients navigate coverage options like collision, liability, rental, medical, and towing protection, aiming to match the right policy with each customer’s needs. Customers appreciate their clear communication and responsiveness, though some note… more...

Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC is an independent agency offering personalized auto insurance solutions in Columbus and throughout Ohio. The team helps clients navigate coverage options like collision, liability, rental, medical, and towing protection, aiming to match the right policy with each customer’s needs. Customers appreciate their clear communication and responsiveness, though some note that choosing coverage can require patience.

Services & Prices
Full Coverage Auto Insurance $100 - $200
Liability Only Auto Insurance $50 - $100
Comprehensive Auto Insurance $80 - $150
Standard Homeowners Insurance $60 - $120
View Profile
+16149150977
Closed Now
1500 W 3rd Ave #300F, Columbus, OH 43212, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
7

Gautam Insurance Agency LLC

Gautam Insurance Agency LLC offers a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, business, and life insurance, with a focus on professionalism and honest service. Customers appreciate the friendly team and variety of choices, though some note difficulty reaching the agency by phone.

Services & Prices
Auto Insurance $100 - $200
Home Insurance $200 - $500
Life Insurance $50 - $150
General Liability $300 - $600
View Profile
+16148040209
Closed Now
1279 E Dublin Granville Rd 1st floor, Columbus, OH 43229, USA
General Services
Insurance
8

Express Insurance

Express Insurance specializes in helping Columbus drivers find affordable auto insurance by comparing multiple company rates with just one call. Their team handles the details quickly, often completing quotes in under five minutes. Customers appreciate the friendly service and significant savings, though some have noted occasional difficulties reaching the office or outdated online information.

Services & Prices
Basic Coverage $40 - $80
Comprehensive Coverage $100 - $150
Liability Only $30 - $50
Basic Homeowners Policy $600 - $1200
View Profile
+16143285472
Open 8:00 AM - 10:00 PM
480 S 3rd St #142a, Columbus, OH 43215, USA
General Services
Auto Insurance
9

Heyward Insurance Group, LLC

Known for personalized service and a broad range of insurance options, Heyward Insurance Group, LLC operates as an independent brokerage offering auto, home, and life coverage. Clients appreciate the team’s responsiveness and professionalism, though some note occasional communication delays during policy transitions. The agency serves a diverse clientele with tailored solutions.

Services & Prices
Home Insurance $500 - $1500
Auto Insurance $800 - $2000
Life Insurance $300 - $1000
Insurance Policy Review $100 - $250
View Profile
+16144567272
Open 7:00 AM - 8:00 PM
2970 McKinley Ave, Columbus, OH 43204, USA
General Services
Insurance
10

The Germain Insurance Company

In 1947, the Germain family opened their first automotive shop in Columbus. They were committed to providing excellent customer service and remained open to new customers. The Germain Automotive Partnership now has eleven locations and nine brands across Ohio, Florida and Naples. The Germain family realized that their customers needed quality insurance when they bought vehicles. The Germain… more...

In 1947, the Germain family opened their first automotive shop in Columbus. They were committed to providing excellent customer service and remained open to new customers. The Germain Automotive Partnership now has eleven locations and nine brands across Ohio, Florida and Naples. The Germain family realized that their customers needed quality insurance when they bought vehicles. The Germain Insurance Company was established in 2015 to address this problem. Independent agency, The Germain Insurance Company, provides automobile insurance. However, it also specializes on home, life and condo insurance. The Germain Insurance Co. is an independent agent that works with many insurance companies to find the best options for each customer. The Germain Insurance Company provides insurance that meets customers' needs. It also covers their most valuable assets. This gives them peace of mind and protects their investment. Germain Insurance is committed to finding the best insurance policy for each client. The Germain Insurance Company is a team that values relationships. Each member of the team enjoys getting acquainted with each client so they can better understand their financial goals. The team looks forward to helping each individual evaluate the options and finding the best plan for them.

View Profile
+16143834444
Open 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
7250 Sawmill Rd, Columbus, OH 43235, USA
Columbus Auto Insurance Agencies stats: 10 businesses compared side by side · updated
# Business Rating Reviews Starting price Phone Website
1 Acceptance Insurance 4.7 98 $5 +16146817926 Visit
2 Solid Insurance 4.3 81 $50 +16148540000 Visit
3 Progressive Insurance 3.1 103 $30 +16149043140 Visit
4 Direct Auto Insurance 4.8 48 $50 +16144979500 Visit
5 A.A. Affordable Insurance Agency of Ohio 4.1 47 $50 +16142217007 Visit
6 Grandview Insurance Agency, LLC 5 33 $15 +16149150977 Visit
7 Gautam Insurance Agency LLC 4.4 17 $50 +16148040209 Visit
8 Express Insurance 3.8 12 $30 +16143285472 Visit
9 Heyward Insurance Group, LLC 4.2 6 $50 +16144567272 Visit
10 The Germain Insurance Company 3.3 4 — +16143834444 Visit

Our Methodology

Best 10 auto insurance agency list assembly and recognition by TrustAnalytica for Columbus is based on online reputation backed by review sources as google reviews, TrustAnalytica reviews and more.

We choose the best companies in the location and rank them based on rating, quantity of reviews and verification (Claimed or unclaimed profile).

Rankings are frequently updated to reflect the latest reviews from trusted sources.

Profile verification is free and may improve ranking, as we prioritize accurate, up-to-date profiles that are actively maintained and regularly reviewed.

TrustAnalytica's procedure for listing auto insurance agency companies involves manual research, review and placement. Please note that some companies are placed here through their registration with our services as every company gets not only access to our Saas services but also a profile that gets listed. We evaluate businesses based on their online reputation, accessibility, online resources such as website and their fit for best 10 auto insurance agency category.

The Process

1

Business Verification

Verified auto insurance agency listings in Columbus are based on robust online activity and Google reviews, ensuring credibility.

2

Business Details

Comprehensive auto insurance agency profiles offer vital details for informed decisions in Columbus.

3

Reviews And Ratings

Real-time customer ratings guide our auto insurance agency rankings in Columbus, reflecting genuine reputation.

4

SEO And Keywords

Our SEO strategy elevates the visibility of top auto insurance agency providers in Columbus.

5

Subscription

Subscribed auto insurance agency services in Columbus gain prominence with extra listing features.